Will Video Cameras Kill Still Photography? Red Epic Vs Hasselblad
UPDATED WITH PETER’S Full RES FILES! New cameras are getting faster and faster each year. In over a decade DSLRs have gone from 6 fps to 12 fps, and now many can shoot 60 frames of HD video. We’ve all heard it before, “At some point photographers will just shoot video and pull the best frame out” but is this really even feasible? Fstoppers.com recently teamed up with Peter Hurley to test this theory as we compared the Hasselblad H3D-22 with the Red Epic. The results are shocking!
Peter Hurley is considered one of the top headshot photographers in the world. Since his whole style is based on capturing the absolute definitive moment in a person’s expression, we thought it would be fun to bring a Red Epic video camera into his studio and test it against a traditional medium format still camera (thanks Cinema-Vision NYC!). Since Peter lights his portraits with Kino Flos, a type of constant light, the images taken on both systems would look stylistically identical.
The question we wanted to know was…
Can high resolution video keep up with or out perform high resolution photography?
The difference between cameras
Camera Type Medium Format Interchangeable Lens Camera with Reflex Viewfinder and Integrated Digital Back
Image Sensor 36.7 x 49.0 mm, 22 Megapixel CCD
Effective Resolution 22.2 million pixels
Color Depth 48-Bit RGB
Color Modes Full Color
Image File Formats RAW 3FR
Recorded Resolution 4080 x 5440 pixels
Camera Type 5K High Resolution Video Camera with Interchangeable Lenses
Image Sensor 30mm x 15mm, 14 Megapixel CMOS
Effective Resolution 13.8 million pixels
Color Depth 24-Bit RGB
Color Modes Full Color
Image File Formats RAW R3D
Recorded Resolution 5120 x 2700 pixels
What is 5K video?
Unless you are heavily involved with video recording, the average person might not know what 5K video actually means. The term “5K” refers to the horizontal pixel count on a video file. Everyone is familiar with 1080 HD video which has 1080 pixels vertically. The Red Epic shoots video that is over 6x more resolution! If you were to pause a 1080 video and pull that frame out from the video, you would have a 2 megapixel image (1080×1920 – 2 million pixels). With a 5K video frame, you have almost 14 megapixels (5120×2700 as in the Red Epic).
For a modest 8×10 print, you need roughly 3 megapixels and a super sharp image to print something usable. The Red Epic can film 120 frames per second at the full 5K resolution which means you can easily print the exact definitive moment on a 17″x9″ canvas (5K is 16:9 aspect ratio).
I thought photographers use strobes, why does this work?
Photographers typically use flashes or strobes to light their images. Videographers rely on constant light. Peter Hurley actually uses constant light to photograph his headshots. By lighting his subjects with Kino Flo light banks, Peter was easily able to shoot both stills and video under the same lighting condition. With his headshot clients, Peter alternates between pure white backgrounds and medium gray backgrounds by flashing his background. The Red Epic cannot record fast enough to capture Peter’s pure white backgrounds lit by flash but it can reproduce his medium gray background because they are only lit by his Kino Flo lights.
For more information about Peter Hurley’s lighting setup and why his headshots are some of the best in the world, check out his full length tutorial The Art Behind The Headshot.