• Originals
    • Categories
      • Gear
        • Forum
          • Picture of the Day
            • Contests
              • More
                • FS Gear Guide
                • Fstoppers T-shirts
              • Home
              • Advertise
              • Meet the Writers
              • Submit Content
              • Contact
              artbreaking1
              artbreaking1
              April 29, 2012
              Corey Melton

              [News] You Break It, You Bought It

              Below is a selection from a New York Post article that I read earlier this week. At first I laughed at the reality of a photographer being so careless around an ancient piece of art. The laughing stopped pretty quickly though once i thought “What if I had done this and had a lawsuit hanging over my head”. There are very real consequences for us as photographers when we are shooting with other’s personal items (i.e. designer dresses, people’s homes or cars, props we borrow from friends for our shoots). If putting everything in writing isn’t something you already practice in your business of photography, hopefully reading this will be the beginning of you doing that. Who do you think is responsible for this mishap? The art collector? The photographer? The Magazine Publisher? Let us know what you think in the comments!

              Manhattan art collector, Corice Arman, says photographer, Eric Guillemain, was snapping photos of her 2,630 year-old sculpture for an art magazine, when he carelessly smashed the rare piece to bits during the photo shoot. Now she wants the publishers to pay $300,000.

              Corice filed a lawsuit yesterday, after she heard the sickening crash and saw what had happened, “I was devastated.” According to the suit, the photog and his crew didn’t use “the due care necessary” to handle the artifact, and it fell to the floor.
              Read the full article here

              Editorial
              News
              Photojournalistic
              « [News] Career Advice From A Professional Retoucher.
              [Pics] It Was The Last Flight Of Space Shuttle Enterprise And I Was There »
              • http://twitter.com/TumbledLight Mark Kern

                Heard about the cameraman who stepped on a rare bunny?

                http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/entertainment/2012/03/earless-bunny-crushed-by-cameraman/

              • http://profile.yahoo.com/6QNHIGY6RTYNTLH2XIAMUFS2KQ josh

                Magazine publisher should have insurance for things like this. My guess is the conversation went like this: 
                Art Collector: Hello Publisher, you owe me money for the busted sculpture. 
                Publisher: It’s not our fault, we aren’t going to file an insurance claim
                Art Collector: Ok, I’m obviously wealthy and since you don’t want to play by my rules, I’ll file an insurance claim with my insurance, which will then go after your insurance anyways, and in order to spite you for not paying me in the first place, I will sue you too !
                Publisher: “We are F’d”

                Likely the lawsuit is legal pressure for the Magazine publisher to “pay-up”… 

                FYI, personal “business insurance” with a single instance $2Million coverage is $250/year for me

              • http://www.facebook.com/people/Georgi-Anastasov/881375462 Georgi Anastasov

                Isn’t it way we have a liability insurance?!

              • http://www.flexiblevision.com Roman

                I can’t stand photogs that walk around looking thru view finder. Look where you are going!! or pay :D

              • http://www.bertmclendon.com Bert McLendon

                Hmmm, If I had something worth 300k I’d make damn sure it could just get “knocked off”.  Maybe a glass case? or electric fence so that numbnuttz can’t get near it?  I’d say she’s just as much at fault as he is.

              • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=506432237 Corey Melton

                haha, sure Bert. Because the photographer would get great shots of it through a glass case. haha

              • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2JNQJTFQYUTDICR5STZABVVI54 Michael

                The owner or curator or representative should be doing the positioning, not the shooters.

              • StevenBarall

                That is why you hire a specialist.  I shoot a fair amount of artworks and I never touch anything.  I blame it on the magazine just as much as the photographer though because a big fancy art magazine is supposed to know better and hire a still life photographer and not just a trendy idiot fashion photographer.  

              • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=506432237 Corey Melton

                hahaha, for REAL!

              • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_WZFNDSQFYXL2TP3NP2AVEQV32U RUSS

                A  2,630 year-old sculpture? Lasted that long, to be destroyed by a simple mistake…All the things it survived since it was made, and one mistake destroyed it 2,360 years later…Damn shame.

              • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000138218536 Vince Smith

                I’m pretty sure I would have a curator there moving it so no parties collector,photographer,publisher is on the line in that case….guess we all learned a lesson on this one

              • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1239063225 Joseph Powell

                Yeah…don’t think I’d touch it myself.  I’d either shoot it where it is or have the owner or another responsible party move it.

              • http://www.facebook.com/The.King.At.Everything Tkae Mendez

                http://www.phototips.biz/2012/04/photographer-breaks-300000-artwork-not.html

              • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=511076504 Tobias Chu

                Might want to get your facts straight.  Eric Guillemain wasn’t near the statue (or taking photos) when 2 people from Art+Auction magazine moved the statue and smashed it.  

              • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1239063225 Joseph Powell

                Oh really?  What if another article comes out stating the opposite?  Then will THAT be true?  Nobody is ever going to say “Oh, yeah…it was me” because human beings don’t seem to operate that way.  But then, nobody should carry the blame until it’s proven.  Unless, of course, you were standing there when it happened.

              • http://www.facebook.com/serhan.mehmet Serhan Mehmet

                At least he got a photo of how it used to look like before he smashed it to itty bitty pieces…  Now lets try to archive that image for another 2700 years…. lol

              • http://www.bcphoto.biz James Beltz

                Eric did not break the statue. At least according to him. I interviewed him and the complete story – at least how Eric explains it – is listed here: http://www.phototips.biz/2012/04/photographer-breaks-300000-artwork-not.html  Just like F-Stoppers, I read the original story in the New York Post. As usual, it appears the media got it wrong and posted without follow up.

              • Connect with Fstoppers
                Follow @Fstoppers
              • Fstoppers Originals
              • Popular Articles
                • List: Top Ten Best Movies about Photography
                • What A Week Of Groceries Looks Like Around The World
                • Cat Beards: The Latest Funny Photo Trend Involving Cats
                • Do You Have Enough Gear to be a Professional?
                • Sounds of the Shutter
                • How To Light a Muscle Car with Tim Wallace
                • Fstoppers Reviews the Sigma 30mm f/1.4 DC HSM Prime Lens
                • NY Times Photoshops Fashion Model - Says Readers Understand It's Fantasy
                • Tools to Use to Avoid Uncle Sam's Snooping
                • Brad Pitt Photographs Angelina Jolie: Results Are Impressive
                • My Top 8 Pieces Of Gear For Shooting Run And Gun Video On A DSLR
                • BTS Video of Fitness Shoot by Lear Miller
                • Tackle Exposure, Skin, Eyes, Sharpening & More in This 5 Minute Retouch
                • When and Where To Style Your Food Photography
              • Recent Comments
                • CliQQ Photography said Nothing beats the sound of a Hasselblad! Would best describe it as "meaty". »
                • Simon wardenier said Really great shoot, results are how they should be, awesome! »
                • Catty in Lansing said I use both a bracket and neck strap. I never pick up my camera bodies with out the strap on my shoulder, »
                • Ihab Mokayed said People seem to have too much time to waste to complain about such a thing, I think that the photo is perf »
                • Catty in Lansing said LED video light is a great addition to both still and video. Last year I had a job at a venue with BLACK »
                • Christopher Helms said What a great video, and a couple of incredible artistic pieces that have come out of this work! The photo »
                • james said yeah »
                • Studio M Photography said Should have waited until night to shoot and avoid the nasty skylight reflection in the hood. just sayin' »
              • Support Fstoppers
                current nikon rebates deals
              • FS Originals
              • List: Top Ten Best Movies about Photography
              • My Top 8 Pieces Of Gear For Shooting Run And Gun Video On A DSLR
              • Canon Photographers Biggest Secret Exposed
              • Endearing Animal Portraits By 18 Year Old Photographer Jessica Trinh
              • How to Go Pro Without Going Crazy
              • Categories
              • Commercial
              • Video
              • Gear
              • Location
              • Strobe Light
              • Contests
              • Win a 30x40 Print
              • Alien Skin Retouch Contest
              • Win the Art Behind the Headshot
              • Black Rapid Contest
              • Win a Lowepro Bag
              • Random Posts
              • DEAL: $400 Off Brand New Canon 5D Mark III
              • The Wednesday Rundown 6.30.10
              • April Fool’s: BTS Of Bar Refaeli’s First Nude Photoshoot
              • Free Training: Learn All The New Features of Photoshop CS6
              • Highlight of Adobe’s Changes Coming Today- What You’ll Use
              • Picture of the Day
              • Cyclist
              • Ferris Wheel
              • Cloudbreak
              • Highway 90
              • Frankfurt Delay
              • Home
              • Advertise
              • Meet the Writers
              • Submit Content
              • Contact
              • Sitemap
              © Fstoppers
              Made by Novum