• Originals
    • Categories
      • Gear
        • Forum
          • Picture of the Day
            • Contests
              • More
                • FS Gear Guide
                • Fstoppers T-shirts
              • Home
              • Advertise
              • Meet the Writers
              • Submit Content
              • Contact
              Feature
              Feature
              September 19, 2012
              Pratik Naik

              Vogue Accused Of Portraying ‘Domestic Violence’ On Their Recent Cover

              This recent cover of Vogue Hommes International, featuring none other than Stephanie Seymour, is under fire. Women’s Right Advocacy groups and critics have accused Vogue of glorifying and portraying ‘domestic violence’ on the cover. 

              article 0 150FB4C5000005DC 952 634x805 Vogue Accused Of Portraying Domestic Violence On Their Recent Cover

              Four organizations (Families, Safe Horizon, Equality Now, and the New York chapter of NOW) have wrote in stating:

              “Choking is not a fashion statement, and certainly not something that should be used to sell magazines.”

              “This truly disturbing image of a woman being choked sends a dangerous message to anyone who sees this magazine – that choking is a sign of passion rather than of violence.”

              “A 2008 Journal of Emergency Medicine study of murders of women in 11 cities found that 43per cent of women who were killed by intimate partners had experienced at least one previous episode of choking before being killed. That is why, in 2010, New York State made choking a violent felony, and advocates, prosecutors, police officers and survivors throughout the State have embraced the law as a way to save women’s lives. In New York, your magazine appears on numerous newsstands and has enormous reach with young men and women. While this cover was perhaps intended to shock and thrill potential readers, the truly shocking fact is that it glorifies violence against women as an act of love.”

              Seeing this cover for the first time, do you feel this cover depicts domestic violence, or do you feel that people are overreacting?

              [Via Daily Mail]

              Editorial
              Fashion
              News
              « The First Real World Nikon D600 ISO Test
              Zeiss Announces Plan for New Full Frame DSLR Lens Series »
              • J_M_A

                She is not struggling and he is not acting in anger. Overreacting

              • robsydor

                I am very close to someone who was beat and raped as a child, her reply to this whole thing was

                “It would be HER body language, not HIS that would portray this as domestic violence. This picture portrays a submissive sexual feeling.”

              • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=574816884 Derek Vonk

                I think it’s a cool shot. I don’t think it depicts domestic violence, it’s a rather powerful interpretation of A kind of lust. Doesn’t mean it has to be on the cover of Vogue but I don’t think a line has been wrongfully crossed here. 

              • http://www.patrickhallphotography.com Patrick Hall

                Stephanie Seymour and Domestic Violence?  Hmmm….I think I remember that story :)

              • Rob LaRosa

                Over reaction. I question that this is even a choke at all. Look at his thumb and first to fingers – they’re not in a position to choke at all. 

              • http://twitter.com/AdamOttkePhoto Adam

                That’s exactly what it seems like. It doesn’t romanticize actually choking someone…there’s just a sexually-charged — but ‘caring’ — feeling about it that I think bugs some people. 

              • robsydor

                word – it’s more like a gun…bang bang  :) 

              • http://www.JettFoto.com Corey Melton

                Political Correctness will ultimately be the death of the western world as we know it

              • http://www.facebook.com/hiroschneider Jaron Schneider

                Here here.

              • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KGIHBUQPQNYO4DHTY233WCSDYQ Jacques

                This is more sexual intensity than anything else.  His eyes are closed and her eyes calmly looking onward says she enjoys it and wants more.

                Complete overreaction and it works for Vogue: any publicity is good publicity.

              • Travis Cadez

                Guess they’ve never seen Helmut Newton’s photo.

                http://cdn.thegloss.com/files/2011/01/David-Lynch-Isabella-Rossellini-by-Helmut-Newton.jpg

              • robsydor

                SO violent…./sarcasm

              • http://www.artripoli.com/ Anthony Ryan Tripoli

                I feel like anyone freaking out about this photo has never actually been choked. It is not easy, in fact I’d go as far as to say it is impossible, to look even remotely attractive while being choked. 

              • http://www.kbledsoephoto.com/ Kaitlin Bledsoe

                Overreaction for sure!

              • apercep

                This is the plight of a group of people who have far too much free time.. It is a sexually submissive posture that she is in.. not one of abuse. 

              • Mike_Kelley

                Wow, harden up America

              • http://twitter.com/BenicioMurray Benicio Murray

                more pseudo-outrage from the daytime tv set.

                /yawn

              • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=563353245 Olivier Borgognon

                soon we’ll be having single color, black square, no image as this might depict something for someone somewhere in the world. 

                we could consider this stigmatizing for :- color people as the cover only shows white, no asian, indian, african etc. 
                - gay as not 2 men or 2 woman- animal associations (where is the cow and the bull : pun intended :D)- etc. 

                It’s interesting, although being in an environment where stigma & discrimination is a constant part of advocacy, it is important to learn to let go and get in depth information.

                Although the following might sound hurtful, read between the lines correctly : Some people in some of these associations should be heavily involved in therapies in order to solve personal problems before bringing some stuff to attention, which are simple over-reactions to something hitting them personally. 

                This image depicts very sexually charged passion, a passionate couple, and it’s great. 

              • http://Keysle.com/ Keysle

                This is what you call “Mayjalook” propaganda

              • Gab Labelle

                Families, Safe Horizon, Equality Now, and the New York chapter of NOW… Are they american organizations? 

              • http://www.facebook.com/ricardourroz Ricardo Urroz

                Interesting. I think it´s nice that created controversy. That opens up dialogue and dialogue growth.
                I read the opposite to those they complaint. I see sexual energy and I see him aroused not even being able to look at the spectator and she´s looking at us, letting us see how she has power over him. She is the one in control and not the other way around.  

              • Connect with Fstoppers
                Follow @Fstoppers
              • Fstoppers Originals
              • Popular Articles
                • My Top 8 Pieces Of Gear For Shooting Run And Gun Video On A DSLR
                • What A Week Of Groceries Looks Like Around The World
                • Canon Photographers Biggest Secret Exposed
                • Flickr (Finally) Gets Total Design Overhaul, Adds New Features
                • Behind the Scenes of South Carolina Gamecocks' Photoshoot
                • Get a Stanford Education FOR FREE!
                • The Story of How Law Enforcement Uses Photoshop to Fight Crime
                • Bulb Ramping Tutorial Makes Complicated Timelapses Look Easy
                • Do You Have Enough Gear to be a Professional?
                • Scientists take 3D Photos with Single Pixel Sensors
                • When and Where To Style Your Food Photography
                • Airline Says 'No Photography' on Flights
                • Tackle Exposure, Skin, Eyes, Sharpening & More in This 5 Minute Retouch
                • Fstoppers Reviews the Sigma 30mm f/1.4 DC HSM Prime Lens
              • Recent Comments
                • JR said I cant download it to my LR4. Where is the Menu under Import you're talking about? »
                • DforDesign said How about The Bang Bang Club? »
                • Steve Wayda said Well written article, but your title "The Photographers You Idolize Are No Better Than You" ... could be »
                • Heather Curiel said Why is the cute sweet looking lady the "hobbyist" and the older white dude the "professional" . So wrong. »
                • Bryan Leighty said Lately I've been using the frequency separation technique for my skin work . I keep a copy of the textur »
                • Leslie said Ha ha what a happy crew here :) -- loved this Aaron and yes it's the kind of finish used in advertising. »
                • Tam Nguyen Photography said I have my iPhone 5 as my primary to shooting wedding. The iPad is only for backup. »
                • TD said I agree with Tim! I own on body and two lenses (50&85), and a couple of old balcars. These get used w »
              • Support Fstoppers
                current nikon rebates deals
              • FS Originals
              • List: Top Ten Best Movies about Photography
              • My Top 8 Pieces Of Gear For Shooting Run And Gun Video On A DSLR
              • Canon Photographers Biggest Secret Exposed
              • Endearing Animal Portraits By 18 Year Old Photographer Jessica Trinh
              • How to Go Pro Without Going Crazy
              • Categories
              • Commercial
              • Video
              • Gear
              • Location
              • Strobe Light
              • Contests
              • Win a 30x40 Print
              • Alien Skin Retouch Contest
              • Win the Art Behind the Headshot
              • Black Rapid Contest
              • Win a Lowepro Bag
              • Random Posts
              • Food Photography With Television Chef Jamie Oliver
              • Nikon D600 — All the Details!
              • 20 Great Images of Lighthouses
              • Mark Lebryk Turns To Tanning Beds For His Contest Entry
              • Dave Hill Takes You INSIDE His Photographs 3D Style
              • Picture of the Day
              • Cyclist
              • Ferris Wheel
              • Cloudbreak
              • Highway 90
              • Frankfurt Delay
              • Home
              • Advertise
              • Meet the Writers
              • Submit Content
              • Contact
              • Sitemap
              © Fstoppers
              Made by Novum