In Defense of Art School Graduates

In Defense of Art School Graduates

What’s wrong with our industry that we are so quick to belittle formal education? Whenever the topic of an art degree arises, there’s an angry mob that amasses, collectively chanting how “useless” a degree is in photography and that the best school to learn from is the University of Hard Knocks. To really understand this issue, we have to first step back and look at the value of art and why photographers are so polarized on the term. Then, we have to recognize that “art school graduates” are not the real problem; it’s the dismissive attitudes toward them that are.

Without getting too heavy into the discussion of what makes art, art (that will be a future article), let’s quickly address the value of art. Art is the way in which we describe, translate or ask questions about the human experience. It is found in every culture around the world, and it has been taking place for tens of thousands of years. Not every photographer is an artist, and not every photographer wants to be. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that. This is, however, an important distinction to make, because, while photography can be considered a skill or a trade by many, it can also be considered a medium for artists. With that distinction established, it’s important to remember that while a photography degree does teach the skills the be a photographer, it also teaches the ways in which photography can be used as a artistic instrument. This is where I believe the genesis of the disconnect occurs – some photographers choose to pursue work and be small business owners (and facilitate other people’s vision), while others choose to peruse art (and facilitate their own). Neither is wrong, but they are very different.

What’s So Valuable About an Art Degree, Anyway?

First, we can all admit that the resources to learn things online are practically limitless. For example, with enough YouTube videos, someone can teach themselves Photoshop pretty competently. Want to learn how to use the lens flare filter? Check. Want to learn if you should use the lens flare filter? Those results are very different. And that’s really the benefit of an art degree in a nutshell. There are an amazing amount of resources on the Internet that teach how to do things, but there are far fewer resources that explain why.  At a good art school, a large component of the education is just focused on the “why.”

The value of an art degree teaches the conversation of art and why a meaningful opinion begins after “I like it” or “I don’t.” The true value is one's ability to articulate the “because.” Can this be learned outside of a school setting? Absolutely. Is it easier? Absolutely not.

While a photography degree does include classes that teach the mechanics of using a camera and lighting, it also teaches a lot more. In truth, it’s not that hard to learn to take a competent picture. What is hard is learning the historical context of your subject matter, how others have done it before you (both in photography and other visual mediums) and what conscious decisions you’re making to be different. Can this is still be learned outside of a school setting? Absolutely. Do most people even think about incorporating these things into their work on their own? I’m not so sure.

 

Why School Then?

Some people learn differently. While certain individuals thrive in a scenario where they are their own guide to learning, that’s not the best use of everyone’s energy.  Some people need structure. Some people want the opportunity to learn in a place far from home. Some people want to learn with a support group of like-minded people. Another key benefit is having the chance to learn from multiple instructors at once, taking bits from each to incorporate into how you’d like to do things, because no one has all the answers to everything.

If your approach to photography is to learn a trade or a craft, then school is probably not the best course for you. Teaching yourself (if you’re very self-motivated), assisting or taking workshops will be just fine for the vast majority of people who want to be photographers and small business owners. For others, it’s just not.

In school, there are classes dedicated to art history. Art history is one of the single most valuable things to study for anyone working in a creative field. As the old cliché goes, you can’t know where you’re going until you know where you’ve been. If you’re existing in a vacuum and thinking that the work you’re doing is completely original, chances are it’s probably not. This is part of what makes good art incredibly difficult. There is a word called “vemödalen” which describes the frustration of photographing something that we think is amazing and unique even though thousands of near-identical photos exist of essentially the same thing. How hard does it now become to be unique (or even extraordinary) in a world that is saturated with decent imagery?

Of course, copying or imitating others is still part of the learning process. It’s helps us bridge the mental gap between the idea and the execution – to see where someone else began, where they ended and to articulate what the process may have been like for them. When Francis Bacon began, his work was derivative of Picasso. Now his work is some of the most sought after in the world. If our own work is not as sought after as we’d like, we must reflect on if we’re actually doing anything different than what’s been done before. Success rewards originality.

In addition to studying history, art school forces the student to work and create outside of his or her comfort zone. There's a good chance that if someone is self-taught, they may not have the desire to work in an area they aren’t interested in or challenge themselves in that capacity. Working in those areas may open that person up to something they never thought they might enjoy or even a new way to approach a current way of thinking. To make it even less daunting, someone is there to act as a guide through the entire experience.

The Pitfalls of Art School

Even though there are benefits, art school also has its drawbacks. First and foremost, it’s expensive. Not everyone can afford to go. In truth, college is expensive. If one is looking to start a photography business, an art degree is not necessarily the best idea. However, if one has the desire and the opportunity to attend, then by all means do so. I do not want to downplay how important both of those things are, and success after school depends heavily on both. Don’t attend art school with the plans to run a business. Get a business degree for that. Attend art school to become an artist, and be strong in your desire to do so.

Art school is not easy. No one shows up to camera class, takes a few pictures and gets an A. Students must work. Hard. Most likely, the majority of your career will be a struggle. School should prepare you for that.

Attending class and doing the assignments isn’t the only requirement. Sure, a degree can by had with good grades but the grading structure is in place because the education system requires it. Grades mean nothing in the real world. Hard work, dependability, meeting deadlines and creativity are what matter (not surprisingly, those things will also land you good grades while in school).

 

What Happens After Graduation

Upon graduation, the student receives either a certificate or a degree. A photography (or art) degree does not mean that you’re a good photographer (or artist). It means you’ve learned enough to pass the program, and with any learning experience, the effort put in always reflects the value of the outcome. 

Graduation is not the end; it is the beginning. Therefore, the next logical step for many is to assist. Assisting is an incredibly useful part of the learning experience. It’s commonplace for companies to take on unpaid or practically unpaid interns. Assisting is no different.  Don’t expect a livable wage as an assistant, but consider it a continuation of your education – a transitional limbo between college and being self-supported. The value of a degree when approaching a photographer is that they will have a certain expectation of what you are already able to do. Some photographers may not wish to teach an assistant most things from scratch. Then again, there are others that prefer someone to know very little going in so that they only know that photographer's process. This may be better for that photographer, but it may not necessarily be better for the assistant. 

If you choose not to assist, remember that the artist’s path is not easy, and hopefully you have something that contributes to financial stability. Ramen gets tired quickly.

Of course, some do get to the end of the program and decide that photography is not the right path for them. Outside pressures (oftentimes the parents that paid for the education) will push for the graduate to find work in the field. This is not a path that someone can haphazardly and halfheartedly wander. It takes complete dedication and passion. It takes more sleepless nights than is worth counting. It takes “starting in the mailroom” and a willingness to tirelessly work to get to to the top. Be honest with yourself before wasting time and energy down a path you don’t want to take.

The Bias Against Art Degrees

There have also been some recent complaints about heightened egos from recent grads. I would presume to guess that this is a direct result of someone being in their early 20’s more than the fact that they have a degree, but that’s just a personal opinion. That said, ego works both ways, and making a sweeping generalization about how all art school grads are egomaniacs isn’t going to encourage a helpful conversation on the topic.

I find it so confusing that there is such a rift over the decision to go to school for something you love. There aren’t many fields where people are so proud to turn their nose up at education, as if not going to school makes someone better or more driven. It is possible to be so unpretentious that one becomes pretentious. We all share a passion for photography. That should bond us. Can’t we all just get along? 

 

Aspire to Intelligence, Don’t Belittle It

If you’re against formal education, this article isn’t going to sway you. It’s not meant to. If you’re for it, all it probably did was reinforce your opinion. The point is not to change anyone’s mind – the point is for people to gain a little understanding. There is a tremendous value in an art school education, but it’s not for everyone. At the end of the day we’re all students, in one way of the other. Whether you have an art degree or you’re completely self-taught, what matters most is the effort you put into your life’s experiences and the value you get from them.

 

A small list of photographers with an art degree...

David LaChapelle (North Carolina School of the Arts and School of Visual Arts in NYC)

Guy Aroch (School of Visual Arts in NYC)

Erik Almas (Academy of Art University)

Bernd and Hilla Becher (Kunstakademie Düsseldorf studied and taught there)

Andreas Gursky (Kunstakademie Düsseldorf also teaches there)

Thomas Struth (Kunstakademie Düsseldorf)

Elger Esser (Kunstakademie Düsseldorf)

Nan Golden (School of the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston/Tufts University)

Michael Kenna (London College of Printing)

Ryan McGinley (Parsons The New School for Design)

Steven Meisel (Parsons The New School for Design)

 

 

 

Log in or register to post comments

38 Comments

Joshua Boldt's picture

Chris, I think another factor in people disliking formal education is the depressing rise in degree mills that pump out graduates who would have never made it through a "real" college. I've worked with many people churned through this system and they are hard to work with, many times because they got the job based on their degree which was essentially worthless. It is painful to watch them struggle. On the other hand I have worked with people who had degrees from colleges with a more traditional approach and higher acceptance standards and they were great to work with. (not always in either case, of course, but very often)

I definitely agree that it may be more of a case of the current generation coming out of college rather than formal education itself that makes them hard to work with. I was at a university for the last 13 years and I saw a huge shift in the students from 2001 to the 2014, both in general observation and in the ones we hired as student labor. They had the same professors and the same degrees over the years, but I found the attitudes and behaviors of the more recent graduates to be undesirable or off-putting in many cases, very much like Lee's "Why I Will Never Hire An Art School Graduate" article described.

Joshua Boldt's picture

I really like having posts from authors with opposing views, by the way. It adds more flavor to the soup at Fs.

I completely agree that there are a lot of people in school that should never have been allowed there in the first place. In fact, that's probably the number one problem with formal arts education today. Many of the programs have been "dumbed down" in order to bring in more students.

Those of us that have gone to school might find it more productive in the future to talk about ways of improving education instead of just going round-n-round defending education against the haters. Unfortunately, that's a conversation that only formally educated photographers can take part in. The ones that never went school aren't qualified to criticize something that they haven't experienced. In fact, that lack of experience might be a major reason as to why so many folks online always resort to bashing art school. If they actually knew something about it, then maybe they'd have something constructive to say about reforming it rather than just dismissing it entirely.

Tony Carter's picture

This whole article could've been summed-up with just the one sentence stated:

"Some people learn differently."

Great article!

Chris Blair's picture

I personally learn better in a school environment. I need someone to analyze my work and help guide me down the right path. Going through Art College at the young age of 35 isn’t for everyone, but every assignment and new class I take, opens my eyes to something I just wasn’t able to learn from the internet.

Jon Clayton's picture

I've found it depends your opinion on what you think further education should be: a) learning for learning's sake or b) training for a career. Art and humanities degrees don't fit conveniently into category b so are inevitably looked down upon by those with a more technical or career minded attitude.

I discovered Photography after a long illness. I self taught myself everything I could, up to point where I felt I could not learn anything more by myself. I was thirsty tolearn to grow as a photographer I was lucky enough to be excepted into one of the best Schools and am currently working on my Bachelors of Design and Visual Arts majoring in photography. This has given me so much more than I could have even hoped for, Its been very hard work and lots of long hours. However for myself the benefits have been non stop. Mentored by top international photographers, learned to grow a thick skin, learned to really bring my A game to my work, resulting in being published in an international art Magazine Threaded, up and coming artists. I thought I would learn the commercial aspect, however I have learned I am an artist. My school of Photography at Unitec in New Zealand caters for both art and commercial photography so I get he best of both worlds. the opportunity's that are opening for me are endless. and like Chris said in this great article, I know now what has been done, when and why to do something. I'm not living in a vacuum but an every expanding world of knowledge and creativity. Its not for everybody true. But I wouldn't swap the last 2 and a half years of super tough work, long long hours Due Assignment meltdowns for anything yes its really hard, but for me so worth it, at the end of the day I get a piece of paper saying I passed, however I have really gained a universe of knowledge that sets me up to gain even more when I graduate. Chris thank you for writing this article it really is brilliant.

Chris Knight's picture

Thank you for taking the time to write this! I'm glad you appreciated the piece! Best of luck!