• Originals
    • Categories
      • Gear
        • Forum
          • Picture of the Day
            • Contests
              • More
                • FS Gear Guide
                • Fstoppers T-shirts
              • Home
              • Advertise
              • Meet the Writers
              • Submit Content
              • Contact
              picture-theft
              picture-theft
              January 17, 2013
              Lee Morris

              This Guy Stole Photography From The Wrong Person… Me

              A few weeks ago I got a Facebook message from someone saying I should check out a particular website. The message simply said “I think this guy is stealing your pictures.” We’ll call “this guy” “John,” and yes, John was using my pictures as well as other photographers’ images and claiming that they were his own. John’s plan of grabbing images from photographers far outside of his state could have worked but he happened to choose me, Lee Morris, the owner of one of the biggest photography websites on the internet, and the creator of a massive wedding photography tutorial.

              The first link that I was sent was to Wedding.com. On this site, “John” had made a business profile featuring some of my images.

              36 This Guy Stole Photography From The Wrong Person... Me

              The image above is one of my flagship images. I took that shot for a big advertising campaign years ago. I put a ton of thought and work into getting that image and so I could easily recognize it anywhere. After seeing this, I showed a few of my friends this page and they began doing some research. In about 20 minutes of time we knew everything about John; his current and previous address, his Facebook page, his Google account information, his current and previous employers, his phone number, and a list of websites where he was advertising his “business” including his main website.


              We found his personal websiteupdatebelow This Guy Stole Photography From The Wrong Person... Me
              We found him advertising on other websites
              updatebelow This Guy Stole Photography From The Wrong Person... Me
              We found him on Craigslist
              updatebelow This Guy Stole Photography From The Wrong Person... Me
              We found him on Youtube
              updatebelow This Guy Stole Photography From The Wrong Person... Me

              As I went through more and more of “his” pictures, I kept wondering if anyone was actually falling for this because he would put a few of my images next to one of his shots and it was obvious that these shots were not taken by the same person. When you see one of his shots next to one of mine, it just doesn’t really add up.

              updatebelow This Guy Stole Photography From The Wrong Person... Me
              As I continued through “his portfolio” I noticed one shot that looked like something I would take, but it wasn’t my shot. After reviewing John’s actual work, I knew he wasn’t good enough to take it so I did a little more research. I noticed that the trees in the background looked familiar… in fact, this shot was taken about 1 minute from my house at Boone Hall Plantation. After doing a Tineye search for that image I realized that he had stolen this picture from my friend Leigh Webber, another great wedding photographer in town.

              updatebelow This Guy Stole Photography From The Wrong Person... Me
              Now I know a lot of photographers would be furious about this but honestly it didn’t really bother me. I think John was pretty stupid for trying to get away with using my pictures as his own, especially when some of my pictures are so well known publicly, but I doubt he is booking any work and this isn’t effecting my business in any way. I was going to just forget the whole thing ever happened but a few friends convinced me to give John a call.

               

              I called John multiple times. Probably twice a day for 3 or 4 days. He had a Google Voice number and I didn’t want to leave a message because I actually wanted to talk to him and ask why he would do this. I called John again just now and got his voice mail again. I went back to John’s website today and noticed that all of my pictures had been removed, and there used to be a lot up there. I assume that John Googled the phone number of the person that was calling him so much and realized it was Lee Morris, the guy he was stealing from.

              A few months ago I wrote the article: How Bad Wedding Photographers Have Made The Industry Better. I made the argument that brides are willing to spend more money for “good” photographers because there are so many horror stories about cheap wedding photographers. Can you imagine if you had booked this guy expecting his pictures to turn out like mine and then he delivered these amateur, snap shot, spot colored pictures? John would have added another horror story to the wedding photography industry. I have no problem with cheap wedding photographers, everyone has to start somewhere; the problem with John is that he is blatantly lying to his customers. If a Bride in John’s area has a certain amount of money to spend on a photographer and she chooses one based on their portfolio, John might win that client over a real photographer by using other photographers’ images.

              As I said above I’m really not mad at John. We’ve all done stupid things before and I doubt he has booked a single wedding from this website of his. I didn’t write this post to get this person in trouble with the community, that is why I changed his name and blacked out everything about his business in the images. If you do figure out who he is, please do not contact him, that is not what this is about. I may try to give John another call in a few days and if he doesn’t respond I may eventually send him an email. Maybe I’ll even send him a copy of our new wedding dvd, he could use it. The moral of the story is, don’t steal other photographers’ work and claim that it is your own, especially mine. You’ll never get away with it.

              Update: I received a sincere apology and explanation from John and in an attempt to protect his anonymity, I have removed the majority of the images in this post. My intention was never to reveal who John was and I honestly wish him the best. Needless to say, John will only be using his images to promote his business from now on.

              Business
              « Is Anyone Still Using Instagram?
              Art.com Acquires Portfolio Site Zenfolio »
              ← Older Comments
              • twolights

                 likewise :) but good to have diverging opinions without bashing. Thanks for that.

              • http://twitter.com/duskrider Andre Goulet

                Unless David charges $999 for a weekend seminar. Then it’s okay to try to emulate him. Morally and legally.

              • Samuel Gatlyn

                All the images have disappeared. Bummer. 

              • http://profiles.google.com/ksuwildkat Rob S

                Wow.  Thank you for the lesson in one way  - a very good one – to deal with something like this.  

              • Chad E Currie

                What is funny is that this guy does not realize that you could have taken him to court and been awarded a lot of money, not that he would have been able to actually pay that money. Not saying that you should, but it’s the understanding that 100′s of thousands of dollars would have been stacked on his credit report simply for stealing your photographs. People need to understand that in America as soon as a photographer pushes the shutter release the images are automatically his property and protected under copyright law.

              • Gary Winchester

                Has anyone heard of the website Fancy.com? Well, since we are talking about stealing images, I thought I would share something I am in the middle of. Fancy.com are crowd sourcing images taken from around the web, from commercial photographers websites and are using them to sell and profit from through the advertising of products. They, and their “curators,” are blatantly stealing known copyrighted images and using them to make a profit. I found this out because one day I noticed our web analytics to show 5% of our web traffic was coming from Fancy.com. I followed the link to see if they reposted on of our blog posts, but I was just taken to a watch image selling a VERY well known watch brand with no credit to our website. There it was, an image we created now welling a 350 dollar watch. Not only did they take the image to sell product, but every time someone clicked on the image, our website traffic was being “taxed” so to speak. SO….. not only were they stealing the images from commercial photographers, but it appears that they are not footing the bill for the web traffic either. If you look at their website, you will see a pleathora of commercial images that could cost millions each year to create.

                Upon inquiry to their legal department, and where we should send the bill, we were told that “Image sharing sites, including Fancy, fall under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and its limitation provision regarding user hosted communities. Upon notification of an alleged infringement, we are required to remove the user-generated content. Prior to your notification, we did not have direct knowledge of the user’s alleged activity.”

                So according to Fancy and the DMCA, they can troll for great commercial images of products and use them to sell product. This is an insane concept and goes against everything commercial photographers work so hard for with usage rights and negotiating those terms. How many sites are currently doing this?

                Are there any legal gurus in the community that know more about this or have experience with the DMCA?

                Please, at the very least, tell the commercial photographers that you know about Fancy.com and what they are doing.

              ← Older Comments
              • Connect with Fstoppers
                Follow @Fstoppers
              • Fstoppers Originals
              • Popular Articles
                • 24 Animated Gifs of Celebrities Before and After Retouching
                • 10 Photographers to Look to for Inspiration
                • 'World's Best Father' Captures Creative Portraits of His Daughter's Childhood
                • Lindsay Adler Shows a Creative Way Of Using a Window As a Light Source
                • What A Week Of Groceries Looks Like Around The World
                • Mobile Apps Essential to Your Photo Business
                • So You Want To Make A Professional Looking Print Photography Portfolio
                • Sofles Infinite - Hyper Time Lapse Music Video Through Abandoned Buildings
                • Adobe Photoshop CC is Now Available For Download
                • LED or Flash? Which is right for you?
                • Joey L. Creates Indoor Blizzard For Unique Portraits
                • Behind the Scenes - Capturing a World Record Speed Attempt with Phase One
                • Use Your Tripod to Create Video That Looks Like You Used a Slider
              • Recent Comments
                • Karl-Filip Karlsson said Give me! and hope they make a 24-105mm 2.8.. my lens is complete! :D »
                • Spy Black said Let's see how long before the hackers break this CC business... »
                • Seagram Pearce said My gran always told me, KISS: Keep It Simple Silly! (the gran-friendlier version) »
                • jorgetamez said There's quite a number of settings to mess with, none too explicit on what they do... there's also the 'a »
                • Zach Sutton Photography said Vista is 6 years old at this point, and XP is 12 years old.What did you expect? They can't support old »
                • Lance Keimig said meh »
                • Aaron Lindberg said I will have to read The Devil Came On Horseback book now, thanks for sharing. »
                • Fernando Castillo said I would have loved o buy your DVD but, I too have a wedding business in Guadalajara, Mexico and the Tax p »
              • Support Fstoppers
                current nikon rebates deals
              • FS Originals
              • Here I Am: The Story of Tim Hetherington, War Photographer
              • 10 Photographers to Look to for Inspiration
              • 1000 Miles, 100 Days: One Photographer’s Journey
              • $5 Fixes For Your Food Photography
              • Final Release of Adobe Lightroom 5 is Available Now
              • Categories
              • Commercial
              • Video
              • Gear
              • Location
              • Strobe Light
              • Contests
              • Win a 30x40 Print
              • Alien Skin Retouch Contest
              • Win the Art Behind the Headshot
              • Black Rapid Contest
              • Win a Lowepro Bag
              • Random Posts
              • Revealing X-Ray Photography
              • 19 Fantastic Double Exposure Shots
              • [Video] Quechua Brings The Animal Kingdom Together For A Commercial
              • Fstoppers Rapid-Fire Interview With Fine Art Photographer And Surrealist Tara Minshull
              • [Support] Ben Von Wong’s Behind The Scenes European Challenge
              • Picture of the Day
              • Inner Child
              • Chase Tower
              • Christine
              • Keep Swimming
              • Fire and Ice
              • Home
              • Advertise
              • Meet the Writers
              • Submit Content
              • Contact
              • Sitemap
              © Fstoppers
              Made by Novum