Color/B&W?

This is what I see out my kitchen window while I'm eating my breakfast and is the edge of Ground Level Tango, for those who have been playing along.

I had a light day and was catching up on older images I'd tagged but never processed. I thought it might be interesting to compare more than one edit of the same picture.

I shot this during a snowstorm (duh!) this past February. #1 is the original NEF file simply converted to a JPG and shrunk. #2 is the edited color version, straightened, color corrected, and slightly cropped. #3 is the B&W version, which is the color version converted to B&W with slightly more contrast.

What do you think?

2 Comments

Hi Andrew.
BW: in my opinion.
CONTRAST: Between 2 and 3. with a little more play of light and shadows. could be in post also.
COMPOSITION: Cropped well. could be with less chaotic elements to hold the vision at the play of branches.
Cheers.

Hi Andrew!
For me in general a bit too busy the image. What the the message you want to convey? I hardly find a point to rest looking into the shot.

Talking about the contrast, I prefer no. 3. It looks like the strongest one. And I agree with Vijay, the left trunk suffers on lack of texture. Lifting a bit the shadow might help here.

Stay safe, dg9ncc

More Posts in: Minimalism, Abstract, Experimental (and more...)

Single Light Headshot

Client came and needed headshots immediately. Set up a single Broncolor Para 133 in the dining room. Delivered 20 pics. Setup, Shoot, Edit and delivered within 30 minutes.

An invitation

Yesterday, this bird seemed to invite the sparrows to take a bath.