There’s so little conversation happening in this group. And maybe on this site? So there a site with a more lively responsive community?
If this place is really intended to just be an advertisement for people to go to your site; then mission accomplished. But I want a community that will call BS on parts of my photos that I screwed up on.
welcome to my world. one reason I'll no longer take part in these critiques because I've been scalded because of my comments. The authors of several of the articles via the main page have openly harassed and made fun of my comments in an attempt to get me and others to respond to them as this is how "they" get paid. Like it or not.. No matter how you respond to these articles, they will get paid. The best opinion is to NOT respond to the articles, assuming you don't like it. So by all means respond to topics and articles only IF you like them and want to see those who wrote these articles get paid. otherwise Fstoppers is a breeding ground for hate and finger pointing instead of helping others become better photographers. I've voiced my opinion on several photographs which seem fake, objectionable or hipster related.
As for the image: B+
Hi Chase,
I'm fairly new here but I wisely choose wich comments I make.
On your image overall it's well done but what first jumps to me it's that we don't see her hands. You could moved the curtains or changed your or her angle. Also the shot in my opinion would been better if the lamp behind her wasn't there, could be fixed in post.
I hope this helps,
Marc