• 0
  • 0
Paul Lindqvist's picture

Critique my dessert shot

Hi!

I shot this dessert recently at home, family where a bit inpatient but i managed to take a few frames before they where gone...:-)

It's Lemon fromage with raspberries.

Any critique is most welcome, also any guesses how this was lit is welcome as well!

All the best!

Log in or register to post comments
8 Comments

I think if you came in even closer so the background was even more 'blurred' and the dessert at the front filled more of the frame I think it would be a more interesting shot..

Lighting is very nice and soft - softbox/diffused light directly behind food with low powered flash on right hand side as fill I would guess? might be way off though

Styling is decent, maybe a bit bland, perhaps needs another dimension to bring it all together, like something sprinkled over the top.

I think this image could also benefit from some post-production work to give it a bit more punch too

Thank you Mark for taking the time to comment!

Well dof is already pretty shallow, so i would probably not opt for even shallower. But i agree the composition would benefit from a different framing, a foreground element would create some more depth without getting super shallow dof.

Yes agree styling would defiantly add to the shot, maybe chocolate shavings, or some biscuit crumbles ? Will revisit this in the next week.

Im sure could be improved in post, i rarely go bananas on the commercial work i shoot for restaurants, for agencies it's done by the AD/RA.

Thanx again for taking the time to comment!

The overall style and composition is good, but it fails to give any context to the food. The viewer should not be wondering if this is a drink, or dessert, or ???

Hi Scott! Thanx for commenting. You have a very good point, some sort of texture would emphasis the type of dessert this is. Next time ill use pastry bag to fill the glass so i get a little more texture.

Thanx again for commenting!

Lighting Consist of

Two ELB400's. One ELB 400 with Elinchrom Indirect Octa 150cm shot thru 3010 roscoe directly behind the dessert and second ELB400 with the Elinchrom square reflector camera left shot thru a california sun bounce scrim.

Camera right white bounce card and a small silver card.

Hi Paul - not a critique - if it was me, I'd concentrate on one of the desserts - if there was any sign of the other two I'd have them further back and blurred more, so they don't take the attention from your dessert. Sigh - being of french extraction, I often describe myself using that word and tell people who ask that "je suis un fromage!" My wife laughs at me, whenever we're in France and she catches me standing open mouthed in front of a fromagerie.

Thank you Jean Pierre for your comments, will revisit this shot soon and will certainly try that. Much appreciated!

Hi Paul -- also not a critique. I think it's very good, just not amazing. the quality we all strive for :).
It's like a nice stock shot -- it doesn't take any chances. i think I would have not uses the bounce card, to start with, or maybe used it with the back light alone -- no other sources. But I like contrast.