Please Critique!
Hello! could you please critique this photo and or spend a few moments to rate it?
If you comment on my photo I will gladly return the favor and give you feedback on yours as well.
Thanks in advance
More Posts in: The Critique And Feedback Group
Bartek M. Wojtkunski
Valle de Pineta — Three Images from Ordesa y Monte Perdido
Three images from a day in the Valle de Pineta, Ordesa y Monte Perdido National Park, Huesca.
Charles Mercier
Not quite sure of which one
I know it's just variations on a theme. But thoughts on which one is better than another? Maybe I'm just overthinking?
4
Last: Aug 29, 2026
LightAffaire Photography
02561 . Vegas II
Sardinia . 2023
Photo: https://lightaffaire.com/all-my-links/?FS Model: Matea
3
Last: Aug 29, 2026
Hector Reyes
End of coat season
Ady thrifted some faux fur and thought it'd be fun to shoot. She spend the afternoon with me and we shot several of her "furs". I hope you like this one.
1
Last: Aug 29, 2026
1
Last: Aug 29, 2026
7 Comments
I would ask what the mood is that you are going for. Is the all that space on the bottom and right of the character necessary. We assume that he's high up but we have no reference to the ground or any scale.
That said I would have pushed way in and made my subject take up more of the image and try to put a fill in on the left side just to show a bit more of what the arm is doing. Also I would have tried to get the light above him is that was possible. To me it comes off as if someone opened a door on the floor and a man is just in a rock gym.
Thanks Adam. The empty space is because this was commissioned work to be used as an ad, so there needs to be space for text
Ahh that makes sense, maybe put lorem ipsum in there for us to see.
I was unsure what you meant by that, so i looked it up. Am i correct in saying that it is just random dummy text?
Not sure what this is an ad about? Is it for a rock climbing gym? Rocking climbing shoes? Rock climbing classes, clothes, etc...
Any reason for such hard lighting? If it was an ad for a rock climbing gym, I feel like I would want more light and it to seem more lively and energetic. Not sure if i'd want to work out there if that's the normal lighting, seems a bit gloomy?
I'm just not sure about the lighting or composition on this one.
Also wanted to take a guess since hes free climbing he's not too far off the ground, and more of doing training for bouldering?
Very interesting, the image definitely draws my attention. I love the shadow and the red. The composition is great but I think the bottom needs to be cut off.
Thank you!