USPS Licensed the Wrong Photo, Guy Makes $3.5 Million

USPS Licensed the Wrong Photo, Guy Makes $3.5 Million

In a court ruling last week, Robert Davidson, the sculptor of a Statue of Liberty replica in Las Vegas, was awarded $3.5 million because the U.S. Postal Service mistakenly licensed a photo of his statue instead of the real Lady Liberty.

In 2008 the USPS began the process of updating its Forever Stamp. The then Manager of Stamp Development, Terry McCaffrey, employed the services of a contractor, Photo Assist, to give him access a number of image repositories. He narrowed down an initial selection of 24 images to just three, eventually settling on a close up of the face taken by Raimund Linke, and in 2010 purchased a non-exclusive three year license, from Getty Images, for an image of what he thought was the Statue of Liberty, which enabled the USPS to print one million copies. 

McCaffery told the court that the Postal Service had already used 20 images of the statue so he wanted to use something a bit different. The image he chose was different, alright; about 2,000 miles different, because Raimund Linke's photo was taken in Las Vegas. And when the stamp went into full production in December 2010, a press release was issued that gave attribution to Linke but not to Davidson.  

After the discovery of the mix-up was made by some philatelic sleuths at Linn's Stamp News back in 2011, USPS continued to use the image until 2014, indicating in a letter to concerned Congressman Elliot Engel in 2011 that withdrawing and reissuing a new stamp would be cost prohibitive. Yikes.

In 2012, Davidson's wife filled a copyright application on his behalf and in 2013 copyright for his sculpture was issued. He then filed a lawsuit against USPS for the use of his artwork. While USPS claimed that Davidson's replica was not substantially different from the original, the judge, based on the evidence presented, disagreed, and awarded damages to the plaintiff amounting to just over $3.5 million. The figure was based on a royalty rate of 5 percent of the revenue generated by the sale of the stamp which was estimated to be around $70 million.

All because (apparently) someone forgot to check a caption.

Lead image by Quiz Zard via Unsplash.

Mike O'Leary's picture

Mike is a landscape and commercial photographer from, Co. Kerry, Ireland. In his photographic work, Mike tries to avoid conveying his sense of existential dread, while at the same time writing about his sense of existential dread. The last time he was in New York he was mugged, and he insists on telling that to every person he meets.

Log in or register to post comments

He deserved the money for his VERY ORIGINAL ARTWORK

This is amazing.

This guy gets the asshole of the year award.

Everyone was wrong in this one.:USPS for the stupid mistake and for not making a deal with sculpturer after they discovered the error. The sculpturer party, for claiming outrageous “loss” after someone used a photo of his REPLICA of the statue of liberty. The SUE mentality in the US. The justice system for allowing such frivolous claims to be taken seriously. Like everything in this country, money wins!

im a lil confused, if they paid for a stock image how can they still be sued

Because it was Davidson's art. His work was used to sell a product yet he was never compensated. The judge also deemed is work sufficiently original, which USPS so much as admitted during one of their testimonies.

I'm with @ja d... Why aren't Linke or Getty on the hook for licensing an image they, apparently, didn't have the full right to license? Davidson's work was first used by them to sell a product without compensation. Shouldn't USPS be protected by the first sale doctrine?

The USPS is an abbreviation for the United States Postal Services which is a vast group of members contributing towards the development of the nation.

That's why always suggested to Liteblue employees to keep their Password Safe & not to share with anyone.

However, you have to remember that LiteBlue is provided for liteblue usps for The usps retirement form is for collections of U.S.P.S staff.

Liteblue is the official employee login portal of the United States Postal Service. All the employees in the Postal Service Sector are given certain credentials which only they possess.