Islamic Seminary Calls Photography a Sin

Islamic Seminary Calls Photography a Sin

According to the Hindustan Times the Darul Uloom, India's leading Islamic seminary, has issued a ruling that "photography is unlawful and a sin." The ruling came from an authority at the seminary after an engineering student requested to pursue a career in photography because it was something he was passionate about doing.

"Photography is un-Islamic. Muslims are not allowed to get their photos clicked unless it is for an identity card or for making a passport." - Mufti Abdul Qasim Nomani, Vice Chancellor of Darul Uloom Deoband. India Muslim Law Personal Board member Mufti Abul Irfan Qadri Razzaqi also agreed with Nomani's fatwa when he added, "Islam forbids photographing of humans and animals. Whoever does that will be answerable to God."

When the reporter pressed them about the issue highlighting the fact that those in Saudi Arabia practice photography Razzaqi answered, "Just because they are richer than us doesn't mean they are also correct. If they are allowing photography they will be answerable on the Day of Judgement in the court of God."

Will this change the way Muslim people start to view photography? If you practice Islam, I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

I wonder what the plans are for the photo gallery on the Darul Uloom's seminary website.
Fstoppers---Islamic-Seminary-Rules-Photography-a-Sin-1

Update: This morning the rector of the influential Islamic seminary, Abul Qasim Nomani, has said, “Darul Uloom does not have powers to ban anything. It is the government that has such powers. Our fatwa department simply issues religious advice when its views are voluntarily sought by an individual for his or her own personal use." He however said Islam did not permit idol or image worship, which is why the Prophet did not allow his portrait to be made. This is why images of human beings, whether in the form of a drawing or photograph, are not encouraged. “But there is no ban from our side,” he said. According to Hindustan Times he refused to directly comment one way or the other on whether photography was un-Islamic.

Image credit: Dave Geffin - [Via PetaPixel]

Log in or register to post comments
174 Comments
1o1's picture

they should crawl back into a caves these muftis.

all this stupid stuff is why i don´t want them (muslims and co.) in my country... they don´t fit in a modern western society and the fanatics don´t respect other peoples freedom.

they should stay on the other side of the planet.

Christian Lampe's picture

Yea! Christians are so much better! you know with their hypocritical judgment of everyone! the way we get to pick and chose what part of the bible we follow! The fact that almost all terrorist activity in the US has actually been white americans (Oklahoma city bombing?)! We never fought a holy war or anything! Christianity never persecuted thousands of people! Go back to your own country because ours was founded on the idea of religious freedoms!

32423's picture

who says he is religious.. are you clarvoyant too?

stick you religion where the sun don´t shine!

and that´s my freedom to say!

Christian Lampe's picture

The point is ive met more americans who should leave this country because they dont realize the idea that our founding fathers died for equality, understanding, and religious freedoms, then ive met angry islamics. I would take a muslim over a redneck any day.

Ian Smith's picture

Speaking as a Christian redneck, I have no hate for other religions or races visiting or moving into the United States. Here, we may all practice our religion, take advantage of our freedoms, and learn from each other. Everyone of every religion has hypocritical traits. As humans we are 'in it for ourselves', though it is important we make solid efforts to respect one another and work together. I have friends and family who have fought in our battles. I support them, but I do not forget that God loves even our enemies. Why don't we put our racism and judgment aside and share our beliefs in a civil manor? Besides, as a believer in God whom created an entire universe, I believe He has room for more than only one religion so long as we believe in our Creator.

Robertt1's picture

"Christians are so much better!"

Bad generalization. Some are, some don't. Those who persecuted "thousands of people" were not Christians. You are a Christian if you follow the teachings of Christ, not only if you say about yourself that you are a Christian. It's so hard to understand this and stop thinking like a fanboy?

Søren Karstensen's picture

"Your" country..?

Shahed Hussain's picture

'Your' country? I am appalled by the level of racism on this thread by dick's like you.
One scholar in one area in one state in one country does speak for an entire religion- try visualising this you numpty

43424's picture

mustafa.... it only took a dozen terrorist to bring the twin towers down.
why is it that terrorist are fanatic islamist?

Al Mansur's picture

haha, way the second dude,... that seminars doesn't mean represent all muslim thought from around the globe,.. In Islam there are also many differentiatoan, just like sect in other religion,.. I'm a muslim and I'm a commercial photographer... I'm Indonesia, one of the most democratic n modern mindset country with the biggest populations is muslim. We disagree with that seminars result which says "photography is a sin". Muslim, Islam is not always related to extreme thingking,... come visit my country if you don't belive,... Go to Jakarta or much better go to Bali and prove what I say, we were muslim but we still respect to any other religions and live together.

Go to bali and found what you wanna see: club? naked girls? expensive hotel, superhot entertaintment? modern society? u name it,...

Don't generalize this seminar which came from India AS A GLOBAL MUSLIM THOUGHT ABOUT PHOTOGRAPHY! We have differentiation,....

kameltreiber's picture

what did their stupid prophet knew about photography thousands of years ago?

Jorje Castillo's picture

They referred to ANY form of portraits I.E. a painting in his time.

Kiz's picture

yeah that makes them look much more intelligent.... not.

Jorje Castillo's picture

I wasn't trying to stand up for them. I agree that these kind of people are ignorant, closed minded and all together a detriment to the growth humans. But I was merely clarifying what *Fstoppers* said. notice that part ISN'T in quotes?

Kiz's picture

i was not attacking you... just saying.

Christian Lampe's picture

I dont think its about photography exactly, its more about making something to idolize. For example, how many teen girls hang posters of their favorite singers? This is false idol worship which is a sin in islam and christianity

Doug Gray's picture

No, hanging up a poster is not false idol worship. Worshiping a false idol is. Having a picture up of someone isn't worshiping them. While I am not Catholic, I have been to many Catholic churches. Inside them are images (be it paintings, stain glass windows) of many people who aren't Jesus. They aren't worshiping them.

Christian Lampe's picture

Thats a really good point. I personally agree with you but i see from the other side too. You cant deny that there are many people that get obsessed with media figures. Sometimes to the point of insanity (John Hinckley, Jr.). I consider myself to be a christian and i personally think that, while there is an obvious difference between fandom and worship, sometimes people can be a bit overboard and borderline worship and i think that these religions are just trying to stop it before it starts. I see it as a test of faith.

sulky's picture

You gotta good point, too! Totaly agree with You!

sulky's picture

Unfortunately, they are worhiping them. They are praying to them, to St. John for e.g., asking him for help and protection, and that's worshiping someone else but God. To ask someone else but God for forgivness, protection or to fulfill a wish, is giving someone else God's atributes and that's worshiping someone else.

Anto de Chav's picture

Ironic that this ridiculous rule comes from the same people that worship a black stone,and check out Iran with pictures of their precious Ayotallah ...

Feroz Khan's picture

Anto, no one in Islam worships the black stone. That is a misconception

43424's picture

they only like to run in circles... these intelligent people....

arthurthecommonhousefly's picture

Talking snake. It's not really productive to throw stones at one, because they all have things that people who don't believe will ridicule.

Brian Bray's picture

Thanks for clearing that one up. Care to address the other point?

Kamel Treiber's picture

Saying that shows the raciest manners you have raised at. You have no right to call any
holly figure stupid .. I’m sure you are the stupid ignorant raciest sick person

tiernano's picture

I see the comments on FStoppers are getting a lot like YouTube or Slashdot... Each to their own when it comes to religion... I do agree that it is a little silly, but "no meat on a Friday" was a Catholic "Law" and "no pork" is a Jewish "Law". both of which are as silly as no photography...

44323's picture

how many jews blow up skyscrapers?
or killed kids as suicide bombers?

tiernano's picture

How many wars have been fought over religion FULL STOP? Forget what religion is doing what ever, they all do it for the same "GOD". its all some magic person in the sky who invented the earth and all the people... when you boil it all down, its all madness...

4423's picture

but the past is not today.
today the fanatic islamist are the problem.

tiernano's picture

screw it... its like arguing on slashdot...

Christian Lampe's picture

How many people did we kill in a war over make believe weapons of mass destruction. In a country thousands of miles away from the country the terrorists came from? Or how about how christians in our country condem others when their religieon is suppose to be based off of understanding, love, and not judging others?

BrotherLui's picture

in our country?
there are countrys outside the USA you know?.
you have to mention the country you live in.. but normaly only americans are that ignorant, so you can identifiy them easily.

Christian Lampe's picture

Hahaha yes because the UK never went into afghanistan or anything. And Italy didnt participate in Libya. People are ignorant and arrogant no matter where you are from.

humunkulos bush's picture

i agree americans are the warmonger of the 21 century.
they are a pest.

Christian Lampe's picture

As the Uk, Germany, Russia, China, Italy and France have all been in the past. Cant we just take a second and stop generalizing people from where they come from or what religion they subscribe to? If you dont realize that not only are all people created equally, but that they all have minds of their owns with their own opinions on how things should be done, then you are no better then the terrorists themselves.

544353543's picture

so we will forgive all that happens today because every nation and religion has a dark past?
we have to deal with TODAYS problems!

Christian Lampe's picture

No, we realize that these classifications you are trying to put people into are pointless. Yes americans can be dicks. So can every other country's people. Yes there are islamic radicals. Just like there are radicals in most other religions. The point is that you cant jump the gun and start grouping all of these people together because what a few people did. Its that simple. Instead of blaming people, try coming up with reasonable practical and moral solutions.

Lars R.'s picture

but i don´t see christians or jews explode themself in crowds.

i see a lot of jihad webpages but not many christian hate sites.

i don´t see catholics doing beheadings.

overall i agree with your.
it´s sure not the majority of muslims doing this.. of course not.

but don´t you think there is a little difference between christian extremists and islamic extremists?

Christian Lampe's picture

No I dont. Westboro baptist church protests soldiers funerals and tell their families that they diserve it. The shoe bomber and oklahoma city bombers were both american. The sandy hook shooter and MOST school shooters have been americans. They just had ideas that they got carried away with. Christianity has been used before to cause harm and spread hate. The basic teachings of muslims are peaceful. SOME people just take them the wrong way, just like they take the bible the wrong way. They judge others and think its their job to hand out punishment when in ALL of these religions its stated that its Gods job to judge. Not ours.

842378923's picture

does these shootings in the USA have a religious background?
is there an "idea" in the background that drives these people to do these things?
i don´t think that´s the case.
these are individuals doing terrible things.

Christian Lampe's picture

And thats what the 9/11 terrorist attacks were. Their religion is not, by nature, a violent one. Islam is a brother of christianity (in fact just as christianity is built off of Judaism, islam is built off of christianity). Hinduism and islam are religions of peace being used to hurt many. Just like christianity has been. Just as you said, these are terrible people doing terrible things. All terrorists, no matter where they come from or what religion they are, have delusional ideas that they are doing good.

842378923's picture

the 911 attackers where not religious wackos doing this for their religion to hit the devil america? .. ah.. noted.

and osama bin laden was not religious either.. just a dirty old men....

Christian Lampe's picture

No they were. Just like the crusades were caused by christianity. But that doesnt mean all christians are evil. Its just stupid people interpreting a book the way they want to.

842378923's picture

so the school shootings where because of religious reasons that is what you are saying?

wow.. nobody mentioned that before... go tell CNN.

organized terror same as amok running individuals.

the US police will love this argumentation.
partriot act here we come.. all your rights belong to us.

Christian Lampe's picture

No the school shootings, just like all other terrorist attacks, were because you had CRAZY PEOPLE doing what they thought was right. It didnt matter how they justified what they did. These were radical crazies that lost it. That doesnt mean that anyone that listens to the same music, watches the same shows or gets bullied is going to shoot up the school just like it doesnt mean that if you are islam you are a terrorist. How is this difficult to understand? have you ever actually read about islam?

842378923's picture

i know enough about the islam and that he is not all bad... strange thing is nonetheless.. no other religion today causes so much trouble.
from the balcan conflict to today....

Christian Lampe's picture

who is he? and whats up with "the islam"? You dont say "I know about the Christianity."

842378923's picture

im not native english as you may noticed. .. but we can talk in french, german or spanish if you like.
he is "the islam"... excuse me if that is not correct english.
as i said im willing to talk in one of the 3 other languages.. if you speak another language...

Doug Gray's picture

So the crazy people of the Westboro Baptist Church (they aren't Baptist at all) do insane things like protest things and say crazy, idiotic things and you don't see a difference between that and murdering people? You really need to take a step back and re-evaluate.

More comments