Critique the Community
Composites
Submit your best composite images for a chance to win a free Fstoppers tutorial
Submit your best composite images for a chance to win a free Fstoppers tutorial
Compositing is a nuanced photographic skill that requires a practiced eye to do well. Thankfully, we had a master of compositing join us to provide some amazing feedback in this episode of Critique the Community, Josh Rossi. Do you agree with his and Lee's critiques?
Congratulations to our two tutorial winners. Santiago Hernandez submitted the highest average community rated image and Mark Teasdale was the randomly selected entrant. We will be in touch with both of you via your Fstoppers profiles to claim your prize.
If you didn't participate in this episode but want to join us for the next one, you can submit your images with a "technology" theme HERE.
It's time to pull out your best composite images and see what the Fstoppers community thinks of them. For our next episode of Critique the Community, we hope to bring in a special guest who is a master compositor, Josh Rossi.
Although Josh has a wide variety of incredible images, he's probably easiest recognized for his Wonder Woman series with his daughter. We are planning on having Josh and Lee provide feedback to 20 image submissions from the community. Two entrants will win their choice of a free Fstoppers tutorial. The first winner will be decided by the highest average community rated image and the second winner will be chosen at random.
You have the opportunity to enter up to two images for this contest between now and March 19th, 2019. Once you've uploaded your image, we invite you to scroll through the rest of the submissions and provide honest and helpful feedback of your own. The easiest way to provide numerical ratings is to use your number and keypad. If you see an area where an image could be improved, feel free to leave an encouraging comment detailing what you think the photographer could do differently.
Tue, 03/19/2019 - 23:45
This contest has ended.
Click on the thumbnails below to comment and rate each image.
Click here to learn about the Fstoppers rating system and what each star value means.
38 Comments
Many of these photos are great but it would have been nice to see some contrast with some less obvious composites. These all look very obvious which makes them seem like lazy choices to critique. It would have been cool to see a photo where they couldn’t tell what the composite was. Sometimes subtlety speaks volumes. Just a thought for next time
I’m honestly surprised some of these are rated so low. There are some pretty good composites that are rated to not even be in their portfolio. Man, tough room.
This usually happens with contest as everyone low scores each other to boost themselves. Or just trolls having fun. Doesn't bother me. All for fun anyway.
Yeah, I get it. Even for fun though, I couldn’t lowball someone to win. I’d rather keep my morals intact. 😂