Upgrading Your MacBook: Should You Go Air or Pro?

Your next MacBook isn’t just about specs—it's about matching your creative needs with the right tool. Here's whether the Air or Pro is right for you.

Coming to you from Tyler Stalman, this practical video pinpoints exactly what you need to consider when upgrading or purchasing a MacBook for creative work. Stalman clarifies early that most users will find everything they need in the MacBook Air, especially given its reliable M4 chip, perfect for daily tasks and basic editing. He further highlights the nuances of screen size, explaining why you might feel restricted by the 13-inch Air, while the larger models offer greater versatility.

Stalman moves into the critical differences between the displays, clearly breaking down what separates a casual, daily-use screen from the high-performance display of the MacBook Pro. He details why the Pro's significantly brighter, sharper, and smoother 120 Hz display matters, especially if you're working outdoors or in bright environments. While the Air's display is decent enough, Stalman candidly acknowledges that once you've experienced the Pro's superior visuals, reverting to a standard display might feel limiting. The Pro’s additional ports, including HDMI and an SD card slot, clearly simplify life on the road and reduce the need for adapters, a point he emphasizes as crucial for regular travelers or field editors.

Expanding on Stalman's perspective, the decision ultimately boils down to performance under workload. He addresses the reality of thermal throttling, a subtle but significant difference in sustained power. While the Air effortlessly handles typical photography editing and straightforward video projects, its performance noticeably dips with more demanding tasks. The Pro, with its dedicated media engines and robust cooling system, confidently manages complex multicam video edits, heavier photo files, and prolonged intensive tasks without noticeable slowdown. For anyone whose income depends on the speed and reliability of their hardware, the MacBook Pro’s advantages become undeniable, though at a higher cost.

Stalman also touches on battery life, highlighting practical scenarios where the Pro's extended battery significantly benefits intensive daily users or frequent travelers. Conversely, the lighter weight and compact charger of the Air make it appealing for those who prioritize portability and lighter workloads. His advice is straightforward: consider how critical each feature is to your workflow. Check out the video above for the full rundown from Stalman.

Alex Cooke's picture

Alex Cooke is a Cleveland-based portrait, events, and landscape photographer. He holds an M.S. in Applied Mathematics and a doctorate in Music Composition. He is also an avid equestrian.

Log in or register to post comments