Pye Vs Patrick Vs Lee: Vote Who Took The Best Photograph

Pye Vs Patrick Vs Lee: Vote Who Took The Best Photograph

Yes, you read that right. Pye Jirsa is back in Puerto Rico and this time he goes head to head against both Lee and me for the ultimate photography competition. We need your help deciding who took the best image!

Below you will see three photos from our upcoming photography shoot out video. Vote for your favorite image and then see if you can pick out which photographer took each of the three photos. Sometime next week we will release our newest shootout video and all three photographers will find out who is king of the hill live on camera. 

Photo 1: The Green Dress

Photo 2: The White Dress

Photo 3: The Red Dress

Which Photo is the Best?

Who Took Which Photo?


 

Patrick Hall's picture

Patrick Hall is a founder of Fstoppers.com and a photographer based out of Charleston, South Carolina.

Log in or register to post comments
56 Comments
Previous comments

It's all subjective. What's the point? To count how many people 'liked' one photo over the others? What does it prove or even mean? Any and all photo contests are subject to the views, likes and dislikes of the judges viewing them. PERIOD

For the fun of it. For the challenge of it. For the sport of it. For the learning of it.

Yes...I understand that. Perhaps I should have qualified my statement. It was meant for more serious contests....where titles, awards and/or cash are involved. Contests for the fun of it, etc are fine. Sorry I came across obtuse. Thank you for the wake up call.

While I like the white dress best. Perhaps I'm a fan of backlit images but there is something in the plant that is edited in a strange way. The green dress is nice but there are elements like the rope that doesn't work for me. I think the red dress is nice but the depth of focus is just distracting to me. The lines going through the models head and moving the plant to the foreground would have helped I think.

Statistically, this competition would've been more telling if they all shot the same model w/ the same dress.

The heavy shadows, [unintentionally?] asymmetrical chairs, off-centre background, and awkwardly posed model in the red dress photo screams 'Lee was here'. The green dress photo looks like something that would go on a fashion magazine, so I'm going to believe Pye took that one. As for the white dress photo... People often say they don't know where to look in my photos, and I never really understood what that meant, until now anyway. Thanks for the lesson!