Which Nikon 50mm Lens Is Right for You?

The right lens can change the way your images look and feel. This comparison between the Nikon NIKKOR Z 50mm f/1.4 S and the NIKKOR Z 50mm f/1.8 S breaks down what makes each option stand out for your shooting style.

Coming to you from Alex Barrera, this detailed video takes a close look at the Nikon NIKKOR Z 50mm f/1.4 S and the NIKKOR Z 50mm f/1.8 S to highlight what sets them apart. One of the biggest contrasts lies in their build and design. The 50mm f/1.4 S is part of Nikon’s newer lineup and features a customizable ring, which allows for added control and versatility. The f/1.8 version lacks this ring but is constructed from a mix of metal and plastic, giving it a sturdy feel. It also has an autofocus/manual focus switch that the f/1.4 doesn’t include. Interestingly, despite the f/1.4’s larger aperture, both lenses are surprisingly similar in size and weight, which isn’t typically expected with lenses of these specs.

The video goes further to explore image quality, where you’ll notice the real divergence between these lenses. The f/1.8 is known for its exceptional sharpness and contrast. Even when zoomed in, the details it renders are impressive, capturing tiny features like skin pores and individual hair strands. On the other hand, the f/1.4 has a softer look when wide open, with a slight glow and reduced contrast. This makes it more forgiving for portraits, especially if you want to avoid emphasizing imperfections. However, it also shows more fringing and less consistent sharpness when compared to the f/1.8.

When it comes to bokeh, the f/1.4 takes on a distinct character. It has a vintage look, often referred to as “soap bubble” bokeh, which can be polarizing. Some may love the unique look it adds to images, while others might find it too harsh and less desirable. In comparison, the f/1.8 has a smoother, more modern rendering, making it a safer choice for those who prefer a more conventional aesthetic. This difference in bokeh quality makes the f/1.4 a lens that could appeal to those seeking a more artistic, less clinical look.

The video shows how these lenses behave under various conditions, such as shooting against bright light. While the f/1.8 has better coatings that reduce flare and fringing, the f/1.4 sometimes retains more contrast, even in challenging lighting. This isn’t consistent across all scenarios, but it’s worth noting if you often shoot in harsh sunlight or backlit conditions.

Ultimately, the choice comes down to your priorities. If sharpness, contrast, and minimizing optical imperfections are what you’re after, the 50mm f/1.8 S is a fantastic option. But if you’re interested in adding character and a unique look to your shots, the 50mm f/1.4 S offers a style that stands out. Check out the video above for the full rundown from Barrera.