There is a short list of books that distinguish themselves from the mainstream of photographic discourse, and even fewer for which a good case could be made that they are required reading for anybody serious about photography. This new book about the art of photography scores on both counts.
There exists an ocean of photography lore both online and in print, and the great majority of it seems to revolve around photography gear and the technical details of its capabilities and usage. This should not be surprising, given that the practice of photography has always involved a strong technical component, sitting as it does at the intersection of art, physics, and chemistry, optical and mechanical engineering, and most recently—electronic and digital technologies. But beyond any strictly utilitarian use as a means of documentation or visual reproduction, photography is, first and foremost, an art form just like sculpture, painting, cinema, or music—and as such, a wealth of philosophical and aesthetic learning related to its practice has evolved over the couple of centuries of its existence.
This accumulated learning represents a body of visual education that, over these two centuries, has adopted, embraced, and even extended many of the creative principles and philosophies described and practiced by artists in other fields that preceded photography. Yet across the broad landscape of photography discussion and opinion, so much emphasis tends to get placed on the purely technical aspects and physical practice of photography that these aesthetic and philosophical aspects of our art often get short shrift—and this, I think, is precisely where Ted Forbes’ new book Visually Speaking: Mastering the Art of Photography aims to fill a gap for photographers.
It is one thing to be a technically competent photographer, but it takes more than just technical competence to create an image that can evoke an emotion in the viewer, tell a compelling story, or visually capture and convey the feeling or mood that arises out of the photographer’s relationship with their subject. In this sense, photography (like any other art) can be thought of as a language or medium of communication, and it is this visual language of photography that is the subject of Ted’s book.
Visually Speaking is definitely not the book you would turn to in order to learn how to be a technically competent photographer in the sense of understanding the exposure triangle, configuring your camera or lens for a specific situation, or developing and printing film. Within its pages, you will find very little advice or guidance concerning the technical or practical aspects of photography. What you will find instead is a kind of guided tour through the visual vocabulary of the language of photography. Thoughtful and well-organized, the book is conveniently divided into a series of relatively compact and accessible chapters that cover all of the essential visual elements that contribute to the art of photography. These include framing and composition, color theory, shadow and light, the use of color and black-and-white, and the role of focus and focal length in the creation of an image, to name but a few.
Just as an aspiring musician acquires knowledge of the relationships of musical tones, rhythms, and harmonies, so an aspiring painter (or photographer) will learn the analogous visual relationships that involve compositional forms, shadows and light, color, symmetry, and so on. As a student of music, painting, or photography at an art school or college, this kind of philosophical and aesthetic education would typically run parallel to the more practical studio work that we generally consider to be the major component of an artist’s education.
In setting aside the practical details of photography to focus on its artistic and aesthetic foundations, Ted’s book definitely takes a path less traveled in photography writing. As such, I feel that it is an important book for photographers. Such books come along only once in a while, and I would say that Visually Speaking definitely deserves its place on the bookshelf alongside some of the other books that comprise the “must-read” canon for photographers: Susan Sontag’s On Photography, Henri Cartier-Bresson’s The Decisive Moment, and Roland Barthes’s Camera Lucida, to name but a few examples.
It’s hard to overstate the value of this kind of artistic education for an aspiring photographer, and by “aspiring photographer,” I mean any photographer who—regardless of the years they have been at it—is still committed to the wonderful, inexhaustible, and lifelong process of learning and self-discovery that photography offers the practitioner. Many of the great photographers, like Henri Cartier-Bresson, Edward Steichen, and Saul Leiter, were painters before they became photographers, and the deep aesthetic sensibility that they acquired in the course of their artistic education is manifest in the powerful expressiveness of their photographs—in their masterful use of light, color, composition, and timing.
This kind of aesthetic learning and practice that goes beyond mere technical competence is what is often colloquially referred to as “developing an eye,” and I would say that, in a broad sense, this notion of developing your eye as a photographer is the principal focus of this book. To this end, some of the later chapters in the book are aimed at helping the photographer mature in their art—offering guidance in how to dedicate themselves to the practice of photography, how to integrate the visual principles presented in the earlier chapters into their art, and ultimately, how to find their own voice as a photographer. And while these later chapters expand and build upon the earlier ones, one of the things I really like about Ted’s book is that it does not need to be read linearly. This is a book that you can take off the shelf and turn to for inspiration whenever you need it, with each chapter comprising a more-or-less standalone mini-treatise on some particular aspect of the art of photography, replete with beautiful examples of the principles it discusses.
Visually Speaking is both an educating and inspiring trip that any aspiring photographer should thoroughly enjoy, regardless of how long they have been practicing photography. There really is something in this book for photographers of all levels. As somebody who (like most of us) has drawn a great deal of inspiration from the work of other photographers, I feel that this book is a great complement to the many wonderful photography monographs that line my own bookshelves. After reading Visually Speaking and revisiting some of the work of the photographers who have inspired me, I feel that I have a better understanding and appreciation of what it is that makes those great photographs work so well, and perhaps most importantly of all—how I can apply those principles in my own work and grow as a photographer myself.
When talk of a photographers "EYE" comes up I never know if it can be learned so to speak! I started in the film days of the mid 70's while traveling the many places of the Mediterranean and also ship board on a aircraft carrier. One can be tourist with a camera just clicking away, it is like someone going to say the Grand Canyon with a film camera and when all are processed and looked at all are look a likes with no real difference the same can be said of city photos of click click for memory sake!
I think the difference is that you spy and frame in your mind before a capture. I do not have images handy and scanned. But just picture in ones mind!
On the Island of Capri where you walk and carry your things everywhere, like a camera and some lenses in a cloth gym bag vs a camera backpack of today. There are many swimming places BUT on very long walk down stars, so you look way far down to a clear water swim hole where you see people that appear to float in the air but really on the surface of the water. This is film days, you take about three images with your 50mm but pull out your 100-300mm for zoom on those by themselves maybe 5 or 6. All you know and remember is what you saw through the eye piece and your little light needle positioned in the little round hole of the Aperture needle. You take the time to put all your settings for each image in your notebook for each frame, that is the science info, but have to wait a month to get the photos back from Kodak in the US! the images are great and clear but your memory is a little foggy of how. My point is yes you have the settings of each but will you return to try and copy or are the images like you saw in your mind of the scene before a click.
This is how I believe you train the eye for you are like and eagle looking for prey, but it happens while planning say looking at a map of a place you scouted but seeing where the sun will rise/set and looking at a weather app for clouds that may be there. You see in your mind what you will race to the location in time for the colors you think will be there! But like a computer program update you learn the colors are best AFTER the sun goes below the horizon as the colors are like lighting pop it comes then fades to another.
Like you study places where the full moon will rise on the horizon and it is the same place every month it is a fact BUT cloud cover and weather never the same this is where your mind plays a film or pictures while you dream days before.
The dreams are your minds eye getting a pre look for you have been there before but on a scouting.
Another is just looking at a scene or place and it just clicks and says capture this but not a tourist type capture but something you feel pulling at you.
Have you ever viewed photos of photo tours and all are of the same place and every year there are many of the same place just a little different BUT the same any way, these are not those of dreams but as a copy machine. Like as you drive or even walkabout you scan left and right but then you see something just perfect, that is your mind saying your eye is seeing some light you need to capture.
I ramble too much but to me this is what kinda haunts me every time I open my eyes where ever I am. Like how do I get anywhere if I stop and capture most everything along the way!
Remember one important thing it is the post edit that you bring out what your mind saw!!! Learn to edit unlike the film days where you got what was near your minds eye vision.
1. What happens when you sit down at your anniversary dinner and you spy this sunset, You ask if ok and when yes comes you grab your camera Before the light fades. Your Eye sees the unrepeatable in a flash but no time for settings just fly by the seat of ones pants, bracketing is the only answer!!!
I'd like to recommend a different book, a book I wish I had discovered earlier.:
"Why You Like This Photo: The science of perception"
written by Brian Dilg
The chapters come in 3 big sections, followed by a section "Conclusion". The 3 main sections are:
1) How we see - humans vs camera
2) How we notice - principles of visual attraction
3) How we think - decoding photographs
(Each section has between 14 and 16 concise chapters to break the main topic down)
PS: It's also quite inexpensive.
I have been following Ted Forbes and his YouTube Channel since almost the beginning and I purchased this book when he announced it on his channel. To be honest this book is a bit of a disappointment and doesn't present anything new or unique that every other photography book doesn't already cover.
I was hoping for something more and in depth.
Appreciate the honest warning. Thanks
Interesting thanks. I always look for new books to read.
Have you ever picked up a book that feels like it was written just for you? That’s exactly how I feel about “Visually Speaking: Mastering The Art of Photography.” It isn’t just a book—it’s like having Ted Forbes right there, nudging you to think deeper, shoot smarter, and embrace the artistry of photography. It’s the kind of book that makes you rethink how you see and capture the world—something that stays with you long after you’ve put it down. Here are my first impressions and key takeaways from this incredible book:
https://kisau.com/2024/12/28/ted-forbes-visually-speaking-book-the-art-o...