Shooting portraits in black and white is a genuine creative decision, not just a stylistic default. The difference between a black and white image that works and one that falls flat comes down to whether the light, expression, and mood were already there before you pulled the color out.
Coming to you from Kota Caldwell, this thoughtful video walks through a full portrait session shot entirely in black and white, covering everything from solo portraits with props to couples work to rain-soaked city streets. Caldwell opens with something worth sitting with: color isn't the enemy, but it does compete. When someone looks at a portrait, the outfit, the skin tones, the color grade, and the background all pull attention before the face does. Strip that away and what's left is light, shadow, body language, and expression. That's the foundation Caldwell is building from here, and it reframes how you think about the conversion decision entirely.
One of the more interesting threads in the video is how Caldwell approached a chess set as a prop. The pieces weren't just something to hold. In black and white, they stopped reading as props and started functioning as symbols, creating separation, framing, and a sense of power within the frame. Caldwell also talks honestly about images that didn't feel successful in color, ones where the exposure felt off or the mood wasn't landing, and how converting to black and white changed the question from "are the colors right?" to "is the feeling there?" That shift in how you evaluate an image is something a lot of shooting sessions could benefit from.
The video also covers couples portraiture, where Caldwell makes a strong case that black and white moves the focus from matching outfits and locations to body language and proximity. How close two people are, the way a hand rests, the quiet space between them — these things read differently without color in the frame. Caldwell also spends real time on location: how a staircase becomes lines and structure, how a city street becomes contrast and atmosphere, and how placing a person inside that environment creates a relationship between subject and space that goes beyond simple portraiture. The rain section is particularly good, covering how wet pavement, reflections, and haze give a portrait a timeless quality that removes it from a specific moment.
What Caldwell doesn't do is argue that black and white makes every photo better. A weak photo stays weak. There's more in the video about how Caldwell decides when a specific image earns the conversion and what he's looking for in the frame before he makes that call. Check out the video above for the full breakdown from Caldwell.
No comments yet