Printing is hard. Rather, printing well is hard. It's been a little bit science. It's been a little bit art. Trying to make digital prints look like traditional darkroom prints is even harder still. But is it possible?
Where Mc Connaghy is driven to create and optimize the tools used by printers, a science, if you will, Underiner's intention was to take those tools and find a way to bring the magic of optical printing to digital. To use a simile, if Mc Connaghy is an obsessed scientist striving for a perfect profile, Underiner is a cross between a magician and a monk, intent on finding the otherworldly aspects of turning light into printed paper and ink.
Travis Mc Connaghy at Hahnemühle
Paper / Printer Profiles
Although Mc Connaghy has several different roles at Hahnemühle, one of his core responsibilities is creating profiles for their paper.
A perfect profile would allow most of the people in the world to get the same print using the same inputs.
Mc Connaghy uses Chromix's Colour Think to evaluate the profiles that are made available to printers and photographers using Hahnemühle's products. Mc Connaghy explained that the real trouble arises because monitors have a luminance to them, whereas most print media doesn't. There is, therefore, quite a bit of work that goes into creating a profile that will ensure the printer can create a print that looks like the image on the monitor.
Mc Connaghy works with dozens of different printers, creating 3D maps of his profiles to look for outliers. You can see the differences between a good profile and a flawed profile below.
In the flawed profile, you can see how jagged the 3D model is, illustrating that there are several outliers that would result in the monitor, printer, and ink not working well with the paper. A profile like this would mean that the printer, ink, and paper wouldn't be able to replicate the color spectrum seen on the monitor. The print would likely be muddy, dull, and exhibit unintended color casts.
In a successful profile, you can see how smooth the 3D model is. This would provide for smoother gradients and print instructions that allow the printer and paper to meet the expectations shown on the user's monitor. This profile would allow for smooth color and density changes as well as excellent color fidelity to the monitor.
When the flawed profile (in green) is superimposed on the successful profile, you can see how small and jagged the flawed profile is. It simply wouldn't allow the computer to transmit the proper color information to the printer in order to instruct the printer to work well with the paper.
In managing these profiles, Mc Connaghy will often hear from photographers and printers that are experiencing problems or quirks. For example, differences in relative humidity, HVAC temperatures and pressures, and even altitude may mean that a profile has to be tweaked.
Hahnemühle's's Certified Studio Program
If you're looking to have your images printed by a professional, Mc Connaghy suggests looking for a Hahnemühle Certified Studio. The Certified Studio Program was launched about 5-7 years ago. To be certified by Hahnemühle, a studio has to prove its accuracy at consistently high standards. For those who are showing away from home and don't want to ship framed work, this is a solution that will guarantee you results.
As with each of the interviews in this series, I asked Mc Connaghy what his favorite paper is. Mc Connaghy's favorite paper is Hahnemühle's William Turner.
No other paper in the world like the William Turner.
Mc Connaghy explained that the William Tuner is made using a mould-made machine. This is apparently about as close to handmade as you can get without being handmade, of course. I've been told that there are only a handful of mould-made machines left in the world and that only a few of these are used in the fine-art printing industry. A mould-made machine lays down the fibers in each roll in a unique pattern. This means that although Mc Connaghy and his team have made an effective profile for this paper, no two prints will ever be identical. Their color and density fidelity will be the same, but they will always have subtly different textures.
Tom Underiner at Pixel River
Underiner is a master printer at Pixel River in Pittsburgh. Over the years, he has helped some of the best photographers turn their visions into a finished product. Underiner comes from an optical printing and traditional darkroom background. Having cut his teeth printing from negatives, Underiner sees his role as a bridge between the technical and the aesthetic. Underiner considers himself a translator, from zeros and ones to a print.
As I mentioned above, talking to Underiner was like talking to a mystic. He spoke of the magic in seeing an image come to life in a bath of chemicals, rising from the blank paper. He told me that since the rise of digital, he's spent his career trying to get pixels to look like silver, to make staccato, on or off ones and zeros behave like the gradation of light along with its almost imperceptible shift from light to dark.
Sometimes, you have to tell a little bit of a lie in the midtones in order to tell the truth in the shadows.
When our conversation turned to shooting, editing or printing in HDR to get around digital's limitations, Underiner suggested that HDR rings false. Underiner explained that it looks soft in that it doesn't sharpen your attention. To Underiner, it doesn't have any edge; it's a poor translation, like reading a Neruda as a word-for-word translation and lacking the poetry.
The paper was built to translate the negative into a positive so that the resulting print was a decent translation.
Like a negative, the digital image is only a partial product. You also need ink and paper to finish telling your story. From master printer Tom Underiner's's perspective, that's what makes Hahnemühle such a great producer, they understand this equation, and they're always working on the paper side of the equation to get the best out of your pixels.
Hahnemühle is manufacturing something that many might think of as a commodity, but to them, it’s something sacred. Hahnemühle sees it as being part of the creation of something.
The question left here, though, is it possible to make digital prints look like traditional optical prints?