Trump Team Admits Video of Spat Between President and Reporter Was Sped up, but Claims It Wasn't Altered

In a political era where politicians can seem to claim that up is down and night is day, here's a new one: President Donald Trump's advisor Kellyanne Conway says that speeding up a video isn't altering it.

The claim is in reference to a video tweeted out by Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders, which captures a confrontation between CNN reporter Jim Acosta and an aide who tries to grab a microphone out of his hand during a November 7 press conference with President Trump. The reporter was not finished with his question and didn't give up the mic, resulting in inadvertent contact with the intern reaching over his arm. He responded with a "Pardon me, ma'am" and then finished up his question, relinquishing the mic after.

The video in question was used to justify removing the reporter's White House access, and that's where the trouble begins. Trump has denied that the video was altered, and Conway either doesn't know the definition of the word or just contradicted the president publicly.

In a Sunday interview with Fox's Chris Wallace, Conway says that "[Acosta] either put his hands on her and grabbed the mic back or he did not, and he clearly did." She goes on to say about speeding up video:

That’s not altered. That’s sped up. They do it all the time in sports to see if there’s actually a first down or a touchdown.

You can see the comments at about the 9:30 mark in the video above.

Ignoring the fact that no touchdowns were scored at the press conference and that both videos, at most, show a singular hand (not hands) being used in the altercation, she seems to misunderstand what editing means. Speeding up a video is considered editing it, altering it, manipulating it, and yes, doctoring it. When the timing of footage is changed, reality is altered and you're not seeing what actually happened. To make matters even fuzzier, an expert looked at the video and determined that three frames were frozen, and then the actual point of contact was made faster to make it appear like a "karate chop," as Conway says, to the intern's arm. He even called it "too precise to be an accident."

Conway goes on to say that Acosta owes the aide an apology. It's puzzling that the aide hasn't come out to say how she feels about the whole thing, but until then, this interview with Conway is the only window into that question.

To see the original, undoctored video, click here to see the full exchange.

Wasim Ahmad's picture

Wasim Ahmad is an assistant teaching professor teaching journalism at Quinnipiac University. He's worked at newspapers in Minnesota, Florida and upstate New York, and has previously taught multimedia journalism at Stony Brook University and Syracuse University. He's also worked as a technical specialist at Canon USA for Still/Cinema EOS cameras.

Log in or register to post comments
113 Comments
Previous comments

Really? Unprecedented? Were you able to keep a straight face while typing that? We're done.

I'll cry myself to sleep over that one.

There is absolutely proof. There are side-by-side comparisons of the raw footage and the altered footage. Try again.

I have to say that there is more bitchiness here than i have ever heard in a girls highschool toilet.

The comments in this post gave me Internets AIDS. Thankfully you can't die from Internet AIDS, just walk around perturbed 24/7.

Never have I seen such a toxic community in my life. The comments literally made me want to take a lie down.

there he is

What does this have to do with Photography????? Man you guys really are hurting to stay relevant LOL

I'm pretty sure the last time I checked and I have covered A LOT of photojournalism. Alterations of ANY KIND were a very serious infraction. Making you persona non grata in any newsroom or publication.

So it's been sped up? Slowed down? In it's RAW form? Yea, stuff like this matters.

Add to that, it was posted by the actual White House in order to 'make a point' or, some other kind of agenda. The bar has slipped pretty low over a two year period. Draw from all of that what you will.

I seldom post here anyway. So now I am searching for the button to cancel my puny profile from this site.

Trump is the smartes and best president in all of America! Hes the voice of everypeople! If you don like him, you are so dumb! KAMAGA!

Tell me what global hottnest is please and why barabara is?

Haha this is so funny! Dumb scientists! Paris Hilton is pretty.

I don’t mind your gay. It ok with me!