Critique the Community

Landscape Photography

With Elia Locardi
Submit your best landscape photos for a chance to win a free Fstoppers tutorial.
  • Submission Deadline: Fri, 27 Apr 18 03:45:00 +0000

    This contest has ended.

  • Voting is closed.

  • Congratulations to the winners!

    View Results

Taken in a single shot except the birds are from several shots composited together. Any feedback for improvements is much appreciated!

Log in or register to post comments

3 Comments

Alex Armitage's picture

Ill comment but it might not be any help.

I don't have any quick/easy improvements to mention outside of removing that stick on the wall in the foreground - but that isn't a big deal.

Personally, black and whites really have to sell me. High contrast and dramatic. To me this seems like a photo that had dull colors/sky and was just turned into a black and white. It's not bad by any means, it just doesn't cater to a black and white photo i gravitate towards. It doesn't have drama, tones, or contrast I look for in a black and white. Obviously this is my personal taste, as I'd prefer any black and white to be dramatic like Ansel Adams.

Now this strictly applies to online photos as well. In print, depending on the medium, black and whites can have totally different feels/tones/impact by how they are printed.

All of that said, there ultimately just isn't anything in this photo that captures me. The foreground isn't inherently interesting. The guy on the bridge to me is the "focus," but I don't know anything about him. Why is he important? Composition wise it's got a lot of things right.

I hope this made sense, as it's a little abstract explanation and less technical.

Fine Ch's picture

Thank you for the feedback!

Other than for drama and contrast, I'd turn something B&W to emphasize shapes, patterns or geometry. And I guess here I saw the various types of lines at play (the bridge reflections on the water, the falling water itself, the structures of the bridge, the railings). But yeah, the subject and the scene aren't the most interesting and the day was dull with no cloud to add to the scene.

I may just revisit the place to take a similar shot but at a different time of day with better conditions.

Alex Armitage's picture

Like I said, I like the image! I think with better conditions it would turn out even better.

Also I noticed you might want to have the birds reflecting in the water if you add them in again. Just something really subtle to sell the addition.