Nice and moody. Not sure what the goal of the image is, can't be about the liquor as that's too out of focus (and there's no brand). I like the shadow on his eyes, increases the moodiness for me.

I'm in between a 3.5 and a 4 (rated it 4). What would have made it higher for me was to see his full right hand (I don't really like it being cut off by the table).

I like the expression, color and post processing. Very solid image.

So much greatness to this. Im attracted to lamp and that is my only issue from moving into the highest scores

Incredible!

Love this.