Yep, I wonder what the trend is these days. For decades, every fashion model in Vogue had to have flawless airbrushed skin. Maybe it's more natural skin now, typical of the girl next door, but I suppose there's a lot of latitude for expectations in that regard. I do know that portrait photography is incredibly challenging to satisfy the client. I haven't done a ton of it, but men always seem to want you to make them look more trustworthy and intelligent, while women always want you to make them look younger.

My thoughts on this photo, for what they're worth:

While the hands and fingers in your blue/green light picture are the compelling feature of that woman, the hands and fingers are the weakest part of this portrait. The degree of red color saturation, the emphasis on the forefinger of her left hand, and not-so-glamorous condition of her fingernails are a bit of a drag on an otherwise glamorous portrait. For a young lady, I think the skin texture is fine. The only other thing that sort of jumps out to me is the blue in the whites of her eyes. That would be an easy fix, though.