Nikon's recent choice to promote the new D850 with a pro team of 32 men has started waves of conversation of gender inequality in the arts. During the uproar, I received a few messages requesting for me to share my own experiences that are unique to being a female photographer. Whether we like to admit it or not, America is pretty far from complete gender equality. Many are surprised to learn that the accepting arts industry isn't an exception to the current gender norms. As to not a let male-dominated industry intimidate me, I try to ignore the upsetting gender-specific challenges I face. But there are a few too hard to ignore as they're present in my life daily.
When I first started to pursue photography as a career in Atlanta, I didn't notice many differences as a woman. That all changed when I moved to Louisville, Kentucky, a city with a drastically smaller arts industry than I had become accustomed to. Ironically, it was the man that I relocated to work for, Clay Cook, who taught me the most about the adversity I was going to face as a woman in this industry and what it would take for me to plow through it. During a crew lunch following one of my first shoots with Clay we chatted about our weaknesses and goals. My memory isn't the best but I will never forget the words he spoke to me that day. Like every day working with Clay, I learned a lot, but it was one simple sentence that I am reminded of all too often today. With the utmost seriousness, he looked at me and said, "It”s going to be really hard for you as a woman Gabi.” No one could have prepared me for the year to follow that would prove just how right he was that day.
"You Should Try Modeling"
I hear this at least once a day; I am being told to do various things instead of photography. This has happened to me at the bar, the grocery store, doctors offices, photography conventions, my own photo shoots, and even weddings where I was the photographer. Before people even see a single piece of my work, they don't believe or approve of what I've shared with them. Because how could the thin woman wearing makeup and a dress in front of them be a professional photographer? Being the way that I am, I have to prove myself, I always ask these people to add me on Facebook right there. They always send me a request and react with an “Oh wow you're actually good“ or similar in attempts to make up for the judgments based on my gender they just made. This is just a small example of the heavy tension I am constantly against as a female in a world I'm not meant to be in. And of course, even after proving myself for years, that I could completely fend for myself, my father still doesn't understand what I'm doing. He has said that what I am aiming to accomplish is "too hard" and suggests other places I could work. To this day I am fighting to prove that this is what I should be doing and will do forever, both to strangers and my own family, something men don't have to worry about proving on a daily basis everywhere they go.
I Took My Gender Out of My Social Media
To detach my gender from my work and to sweep it under the rug, I stopped posting images of myself, something Clay suggested I do to be taken more seriously in spite of being female. Sadly, it worked, people began to appreciate my work once they were no longer getting stuck at the initial shock that this tiny woman created it. Now when you do come across a post with me in it, my back might be turned or my face covered and behind the scenes, images went from being of me in action to photos of my camera.
Always Wearing Some Sort of Camouflage
I respond to many comments where followers mistake me for being a man and it's pretty funny. I've even met random social media followers in person who have tilted their heads in confusion or disappointment when they realize I'm a female. In attempts to neutralize peoples reactions to me, I make sure to put together outfits that aren't too girly when I wake up every day. I’ve come to realize that for some reason the more feminine I look, the younger and less experienced I seem to people I shake hands with. When I walk out my door in a nice dress and shiny shoes I rarely make any promising business connections. But when I throw on jeans, a leather jacket and boots with my hair slicked back, I am treated drastically different. Even though I am the same artist and businesswoman while wearing a dress, because of my gender I have to provide reassurance with a tough physical appearance.
It's a bit unnerving for me to look back on the girl at lunch a year and a half ago because back then I had no idea I'd have to evolve tremendously, solely to make up for the disadvantages my gender causes me. I got tough, courageous, vigorous, or according to my thesaurus: ”manly” is what I became. The only real difference there is to being a woman in the industry is that on top of perfecting our craft we have to learn how to be a man.
Images used with permission.
I do tend to expect a ending summary statement to be a summary of the article. But in your opinion, what is the "Education" we are to gain from hearing one person's opinion of a complex issue? If it was speaking about the entire gender and the issues all photographers face, I could see it as an education article. But if what you are saying was the intended focus of it, just one person's personal issues, what is the general public supposed to learn?
I don't see this as an education article either. If you consider it to be an education article then I guess the lesson you are providing is this last sentence "The only real difference there is to being a woman in the industry is that on top of perfecting our craft we have to learn how to be a man." I do not agree at all with that statement.
You are right, I am lucky. Not because I'm not affected by these things, I am affected, but because I'm lucky because I look at these problems as a chance to improve myself rather than a chance for self-pity and a chance to blame others. There's something deeply disturbing about this line of thinking that neatly puts people into groups and then awards victim points to the different groups based on perceived oppression. Once again, I'm not denying that people face different obstacles, I just believe that there is more power on focusing on the solution than never looking past the problem. Life is difficult, life requires effort. But what would I know? According to you I'm unaffected by these things. A convenient but completely incorrect viewpoint.
Yes, by virtue of you being a man, I do believe that you're unaffected by issues women face by virtue of them being women. Again, you seem awfully eager to claim that this article is about pity or a victim mentality. You said yourself, people should focus on a solution. I agree. How can we start to look at solutions if we can't come to a consensus on the existence of a problem? You seem to think it's impossible to "improve [one's self]" and "overcome" without also addressing injustices in the world. It's not.
An article about being a woman photographer that only talks about the negatives and doesn't talk about the positives and the places she has the advantage, yeah I could see how someone could see it as someone trying to play a victim.
Be extremely careful with that mindset Alex. Grouping people based on characteristics, especially those that they have no control over can lead to all sorts of problems. Even if a person does not belong to the group you've assigned them to doesn't mean that they don't have valuable insight on the matter. Ignore those people at your own peril. Experience is great but it's not the only form of wisdom and it should not be treated as such.
In fact, I think is the issue that is dividing people so badly. Assigning merit based on perceived group roles. It is group think (George Orwell) and I'll have nothing to do with that line of thinking.
Also you are not correct that there isn't the consensus that there is a problem. Where we have a variance is in the perceived magnitude of the problem. As to your last sentence I don't think that at all.
Alex the article was not about sexism in photography it was about being a female in photography. If the article was to be educational and about sexism, it needed to address sexism from all sides. While scouting future shot locations in a state park I was basically accused of being a pervert with a camera because 1) I had a camera, 2) there were kids in this large park and 3) I was a male in my 40's. Even though I was nowhere near the kids and shooting the landscape and buildings. A lady came up to me and asked me what I was doing. Then proceed to take photos of me with her cell phone. This would not have happened to my wife or my daughters if they had a camera. Sexism and age(ism). Yes Alex this is an important topic and should be discussed but the article did not do this. I'm not judging the article by Gabrielle being a female - I'm judging the article on the quality of addressing the issue at hand which is sexism and I don't think it addressed it well.
Thanks Alex for making me feel like I'm not failing haha ;))
Honestly surprised it's that hard for female photographers doing editorial work nowadays. Three I think do fabulous work:
- Renee Robyn
- Lindsay Adler
- Jingna Zhang
Impressively, I think the last one does the best editorial and fashion work...and if you think there is a lot of male bias in the US fashion industry, you haven't worked in Asian countries 😉
As the father of only one daughter, I commend YOUR intestinal fortitude. ;-)
Thank you!
So, why DIDN'T you find a real job? ;-)
This article sparked some curiosity in my head so I Googled a few things and came across this article on a website y'all may have heard of.... https://fstoppers.com/video/editorial-photography-it-still-mans-world-6793
Interesting article which compliments this one and also reiterates some of the comments made by readers.
The only thing I have to nitpick about the article I linked is the pay disparity. I don't believe enough analysis was done regarding the pay gap. On the one hand, we see that the average rate of pay for men is $35,500 and for women it's $16,300. On the other hand, we also see in the article that it's looking like an older man vs younger woman breakdown and in practically all industries, those with more experience and time on the job tend to make more so based on that, the average pay for men SHOULD be higher (if the industry follows typical pay norms). (and by "should" I'm referring to expectations, not worth/value) I don't know if men making more than twice as much is justifiable (I'm guessing not, but don't have any data to back that up). I think it'll be interesting to see what happens in 10-20 years when all the "old guys" retire and women dominate the ranks. Especially women who've been at it for 20-40 years.
Being a smart ass, I think I might have a hard time (or a great time, not sure) putting up with comments from men. If I were a woman...
Man: you should try modeling
Me: I'm better at making magic from behind the camera
Man: that's a big lens for a little girl
Me: Oh, I don't have any problem keeping this thing up all day. Sorry if you do...
Man: *trying to teach a woman about something/anything*
Me: yeah, I learned that when I was new to photography 20 years ago.
This article will really benefit my photography.
Dr. Phil told me to tell you, "It's not about you!" ;-)
Can we just take a minute to realize that the vast majority of comments on this article were made by men (myself included), and as my wife often reminds me, I have never been and will never be a woman. So to comment on what it feels like to be in that skin or attack someone for trying to explain something from their perspective is ludicrous. I am disappointed in any industry, and sadly today that is near every industry, that treats women differently from men doing the same job. I personally see it every day, and know from my experiences through the women in my life that it is pervasive. Gabrielle, I'm sorry for your experiences, sounds like you've had to put up with some shit that no one should have to deal with, I only wish that someday you can be exactly who you are and not be treated any differently for doing so. Good luck and stay strong.
Did your wife type this or just tell you what to type? ;-)
We do, but frankly for most of us this isn't actually news.
And for most men they approach this topic with the same expression, and about as much depth, as when they first found out a tomato is a fruit. Whhhhaaaaaaattttttt?!?!?!?!?!
Can I get your email address so I can write and ask you what I think about everything? smh
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_troll
Oh no! You called me a troll! I'm melting... smh
And women don't believe that?
I find it interesting that you used the word complain. This isn't complaining, it's educating. Because if we don't talk about the crap that goes on behind the scenes we can't fix it. And honestly when you consider how much traction the #metoo campaign has had around the world over the last few months I would argue that for a percentage of men this IS news.
As an experiment I created a Instagram account using a female profile pic with my content. It received 10x the followers than my male profile... Apparently if I was more pretty then handsome I would have a bigger fan base but till short dark Italian guys are the rage I will just keep on keeping on!!! We all have our own obstacles don't create
more by listening to others...
The responses to this post have been predictably tone deaf and missing the point entirely. THANK YOU for sharing your experiences that myself and every male photographer could never fathom. This is a male dominated industry on just about every level, and being a man unfairly affords privilege when advancing throughout a career. I have assisted and worked along side some incredible women in my career, and I look to them as mentors and friends. They shoot in markets that are not only male dominated, but intensely competitive and I've seen first hand the sacrifices and extra steps they make to be on that level. It's everything you described; dressing a certain way, talking a certain way, having to appear anonymous to be considered for jobs. I've also heard stories from these women about clients passing on them specifically because they are women. These are some of the best photographers I know! Award winners, masters in lighting and connecting with subjects, and it still happens to them. I didn't have to ask for proof, or say "well, maybe it was..." or wait to hear both sides. I believe them because I know this industry and know that it is much different for me. Thank you again, Gabrielle. These are important conversations to have, and I appreciate you sharing yours.