Buying a camera because of its "color science" is one of the most common and costly mistakes in photography. Whether it's Fujifilm, Leica, or any other brand with a devoted following, the idea that one manufacturer has access to a secret color palette that others don't is worth examining before you spend thousands of dollars chasing it.
Coming to you from James Popsys, this practical video puts that claim to the test directly in Lightroom, using raw files from three very different cameras: the Leica SL3, a Sony a7R V, and a Fujifilm medium format body. Popsys shoots the same scenes with all three, then works through the edits on screen, using mostly Lightroom's HSL module to pull the files toward a common look. The process is deliberately rough, not a lab test, but that's actually the point. He's not trying to prove the cameras are identical. He's trying to show that the differences aren't the insurmountable creative barriers the marketing would have you believe. Even without using a color calibration tool, he gets the files looking remarkably similar with a handful of targeted adjustments to hue, luminance, and white balance.
One of the more interesting moments comes when Popsys applies a Fujifilm preset to a Sony raw file and works backward from there, adjusting reds, oranges, and blues until the Sony output sits comfortably next to the Fujifilm version. The church-by-the-sea scene he uses for this is particularly telling because the Fujifilm rendering has a warmth in the yellows and oranges that feels distinctly "Fuji," yet within a few minutes of work in the HSL panel, the Sony file is reading the same way. He's also shooting the Leica with a Voigtländer Ultron 35mm f/2 rather than a native Leica lens, which adds another variable and undercuts the idea that the "Leica look" is some mystical property of the system.
Popsys also makes a practical point about how to get the look of a camera you don't own: rent it for a day, shoot the same scenes side by side with your current camera, and build a preset in post. He's clear that this approach requires some time in Lightroom, but argues it's far less expensive than buying an entirely different system to chase a color profile. The second half of the video shifts into territory that might actually change how you think about which camera to buy next, and what feature Popsys argues actually does justify switching systems. Check out the video above for the full breakdown from Popsys.
No comments yet