Converting color images to black and white in Lightroom often produces flat, uninspiring results that lack the punch of dedicated monochrome cameras. The secret isn't in expensive hardware but in understanding how to properly handle the conversion process and subsequent editing workflow.
Coming to you from Jeff and Sarah G Ascough of Walk Like Alice, this practical video demonstrates why monochrome cameras don't automatically create better black and white images than color conversions. Ascough explains that while dedicated monochrome sensors force you to think in black and white during capture, the actual editing process treats converted color files and native monochrome files very similarly. He proves this point by showing examples where viewers couldn't distinguish between images shot on monochrome versus color cameras. The key advantage of monochrome cameras lies in the mindset they create, not always in superior image quality. Once you convert a color file using proper profiles, the editing workflow becomes virtually identical regardless of your camera's sensor type.
Ascough's approach centers on using tone curves rather than basic panel adjustments for most black and white editing work. He demonstrates how the tone curve provides superior control over light and dark areas compared to traditional sliders. His method involves setting proper black and white points first, then using multiple brush masks with tone curve adjustments to selectively brighten and darken specific areas of the image. This creates a more natural dodging and burning effect that mimics traditional darkroom techniques. The video shows how he transforms a relatively flat street photograph into a dramatic image with enhanced contrast and depth through careful mask application and curve adjustments.
The workflow emphasizes planning before editing rather than randomly adjusting sliders until something looks right. Ascough examines each image first to determine which areas need enhancement and which should be subdued. His hardware setup includes a Logitech MX Master mouse programmed with custom buttons for common editing functions and an Elgato Stream Deck for less frequently used tools. This streamlined approach eliminates most keyboard interaction and speeds up the editing process significantly. He also stresses the importance of proper monitor calibration and consistent lighting conditions for professional-level work, though acknowledges this may be overkill for casual social media posting. Check out the video above for the full rundown from Ascough.
